Showing posts with label Quick Hits. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Quick Hits. Show all posts

Wednesday, February 10, 2021

Quick Hits: Shultz on Climate Change, The Minimum Wage, and Liz Cheney

 A few links and quick thoughts on three different subjects today:

1. George Shultz passed away away on Sunday at the age of 100 (!). Shultz was a Republican of a different era, who no doubt looked at the GOP of today with a combination of confusion and frustration. Perhaps, as my straight ticket voting grandmother has said, he was glad he was near the end and wouldn't have to deal with politics anymore. Shultz was Secretary of State for Ronald Reagan when Reagan decided it was time to take action to limit the compounding damage to the Earth's ozone layer. As this 2019 article from Forbes notes, there was far less conclusive science in the 1980s about the damage to the ozone layer than their is today regarding climate change. 

Thing about that: in the 1980s scientists were legitimately divided on the issue of the ozone layer being damaged, to what degree, or what to do about it. And a conservative Republican President, in the words of Shultz:

"(D)id something that nobody ever does anymore ... (President Reagan) went to the scientists who didn't agree and put his arm around them and said, 'We respect you, but you do agree that if it happens it's a catastrophe, so let's take out an insurance policy." 

Imagine a Republican at any significant level of government doing something similar today with their own party. Staking out a position that, if wrong, still wouldn't hurt us, but if right might save us. It's hard to imagine any Republican taking a progressive stance on combating climate change, let alone the party head (as President Reagan was) doing so. Shultz truly was from a different era, and era that is rapidly passing on. 

2. Interesting fact check from The Dispatch on the minimum wage debate. While this site is pretty conservative, they cite legitimate sources in establishing that President Biden's statement that "all the economics show" that a minimum wage will be a boon for the economy isn't accurate. Of course, the Democrats would cite other studies and statistics to tell you raising the minimum wage to $15 an hour will be like a rising tide raising all ships. Ultimately, the truth is that it's unlikely that all economists will agree on anything, given their various economic-political view points. But it's probably a pretty safe bet to say that whatever action is taken (including inaction) will have far reaching consequences. Given that many states (29 plus the District of Columbia) have already established minimum wages above the national standard of $7.25 an hour there is probably a middle ground that makes sense. It would probably also make sense to tether the minimum wage to economic factors year to year or every five to ten years to ensure that we don't end up in a situation where the federal minimum wage is so far below the poverty line again. 

3. Finally, Axios reported that Kevin McCarthy, the House Minority Leader, told Liz Cheney she needed to apologize for voting to Impeach President Trump. Cheney, a skilled tactical politician, called the bluff and survived the secret ballot in the Republican caucus to remove her from the leadership. She remains the number three in the GOP House hierarchy, and has continued to stake out her position as an anti-Trump voice in the party. It is hard to imagine how badly McCarthy and other leadership must hope President Trump fades into oblivion to allow them to unite against the Biden administration without litmus tests of loyalty to MAGA. That said, with fringe candidates like Representatives Taylor Greene and Boebert continuing to stake out more and more real estate on the conspiracy theory fringe it's hard to imagine the party unifying over much in the near term. At any rate, good on Representative Cheney for sticking to her position, voting her conscious, and staring down the attempt to get her to reverse course for political survival. Our government would be far better with more members, on both sides of the aisle, willing to do the same. 

Wednesday, February 3, 2021

The Future of the Economy

 A very brief post today, but I did want to speak a bit to GM's recent announcement that they will go all electric by 2035, phasing out all gas and diesel engines. This is an ambitious plan, to say the least, given that they are just over four years since releasing their first full service electric car into the market. That said, fortune favors the bold (most times), and I suspect this will end up being a good move for GM in the long term. 

I've often been somewhat perplexed by both the Democrats and Republicans approaches to alternative (green) energies. This seems to be an area where there are a few undebatable facts:

1. fossil fuels are finite, and likely to run out this century. This will lead to catastrophic shortages long before the last feasible resource is pulled from the ground.

2. This, in turn, makes it pretty clear that whichever nation manages to master green, renewable energies will dominate the globe economically by the end of this century. 

3. The US became a world power in the 20th century on the strength of our natural resources. We used that strength to position ourselves well to maintain global influence as the world became smaller with globalization. If we want to maintain some semblance of that international influence, as well as the domestic lifestyle, we have to create a modern day economy that thrives on whatever the next wave of energy is. 

That argument, conveniently and intentionally, leaves aside the "hottest button" in this argument, which is climate change*. I, for one, think this part of the argument is as persuasive as it is undeniable. I also recognize that the discussion on climate change unfortunately falls into "facts are not as viable as my own opinion" territory. Still, conservative or liberal I think we all have a stake hold in the economy of the future, and green energy is inarguably going to be the linchpin to economic viability, let alone dominance, throughout the remainder of the 21st century and into the 22nd. 

I cannot fathom how that isn't a winning argument that both sides of the political spectrum can rally around, but GM, at least, seems to have bought into phasing out fossil fuel dependency as a factor in their long term economic viability. It should be interesting to see if Ford or another major manufacturer follows suite. Regardless, good on GM for taking a bold position and trying to lead a major portion of the US industrial economy into the future realistically, as opposed to so many segments that seem comfortable keeping their collective heads in the sand. 

*By the way, if you didn't see, 2020 tied 2016 as the hottest year on record globally. Yeah, this stuff is real, we (human beings) are the single biggest contributor, and bad things are going to continue to happen as the globe warms. 

Monday, February 1, 2021

Hank Aaron, BLM and a Reflection on Black History Month

As we venture further into 2021 we enter February, and with it Black History Month. 2020 brought us a year of greater clarity regarding where race relations stand in our country, and how far from equality we still remain. The Black Lives Matter protests through the year sparked counter protests, counter movements, and a great deal of social commentary. All of these things fell short of simply acknowledging the truth: America's original sin, that of slavery and deeply ingrained racism, is alive and strong today. That is not to say any aspect of this discussion is simple; quite the opposite, all of it is complex and multi-layered. But if we cannot start from the position that racism is still a strong factor in American society then it's hard to start a dialogue to move forward. 

I thought quite a bit about 2020, Black Lives Matter, and the state of race relations when reading this article about Hank Aaron's life. Aaron, who died on January 21, 2021, was the "home run king" of baseball from 1974 until Barry Bonds passed him in 2007. Both Bonds and Aaron dealt with pushback as they approached the records, but whereas Bonds pushback was related to his reported use of performance enhancing drugs (at least on the surface), the vitriol directed at Aaron was overtly racist. If you read the article, which was published on The Ringer, you'll get vibrant examples of the hate mail and outright death threats Aaron dealt with as he approached the record, which had been held since 1921 by Babe Ruth. 

Part of my struggle in engaging in discussions with certain segments of the American population is the way in which they want to open scientific or data driven fact to debate. This is true in the area of disproportionality statistics as well. We know that black Americans are far more likely to be killed in police shootings than white Americans. We also know that there are significant disparities in the area of healthcare and health outcomes. Further, we also know that there are significant gaps in socioeconomic status between black Americans and their white counterparts, as well as frequency and impact of traumatic events in childhood. These truths, along with others, are well researched and proven. They are not a matter of opinion; they are a matter of fact. 

I'm currently reading Jon Meacham's book "His Truth is Marching on: John Lewis and the Power of Hope." While I have a ways to go in the book, reading through Lewis' early life, and realizing the relative proximity of full blown Jim Crow era America is always something that shakes me to my core. I faced that same reality reading the articles about Aaron after his death, realizing how much of his career was played in Jim Crow America. I am a sucker for pointing out how terribly human beings conceptualize time; what seems to be a "long time ago" is really the blink of an eye. The impact of what happened a generation ago cannot be understated. Simply put, I am more likely to succeed in this world because of who my parents are and where I was born. The same was true for them, and so on. 

Of course, many people rise above their "station in life," but on the whole we cannot afford to pretend that slavery from 1619 through the end of the Civil War, coupled with systemic overt racism, as well as de facto covert racism, hasn't led to the myriad of studies I noted above. As we enter Black History Month I hope that in 2021 we can take a step closer to acknowledging these impacts society wide, and committing to work on tangible action to help reduce socioeconomic inequality, justice system inequality, health inequality and childhood trauma inequalities, among other aspect I did not note. The reality is that we are far to comfortable as a society to let generations pass and let the problems change, without making the hard decisions necessary to resolve the root issues that led to and perpetuate the problems in the first place. 

Wednesday, January 27, 2021

Transitions, Pardons, and History

 So I have reflected a bit about the completely abnormal nature of the Trump Presidency in the last week. There are certainly no shortage of areas to mine for differences, but two came to mind: transitions and pardons. I am an avid reader of political memoirs and, on Inauguration night there was a video of the three Presidents immediately preceding President Trump which made me think of a few that do a good job putting the Presidency into context. That context, in turn, helps to show just how (dangerously) different the Trump Presidency was. 

The video, which appears to be recorded after the Inauguration ceremony, features Presidents Obama, Bush, and Clinton standing around and talking about the office, and the nature of taking the Oath of Office and becoming President. Watching these three men stand around and discuss the nature of taking that responsibility on made me reflect on a book by Jon Meacham entitled "Destiny and Power". This book, about George H.W. Bush, covers the man's life, including his time in office. It also has a reflection on the letter he wrote Bill Clinton and left in the Oval Office, in which President Bush told the man who had just defeated "your success is now our country's success. I'm rooting for you." 

Compare that to the nearly two and a half months of President Trump refusing to acknowledge that which was obvious: he had lost, and not necessarily closely, to Joe Biden. There is no doubt that George H.W. Bush was disappointed about losing to Bill Clintion. Bush was a man who rushed to enlist in the armed services to fight in World War II, a man who was shot down over the Pacific in combat, and a man who devoted his life to public service. You are not that sort of person, let alone a person who builds a political career that makes the Presidency even a discussion point, without being competitive. Extremely competitive. And yet, "I'm rooting for you." And, more impressively, everything George H.W. Bush did as former President Bush demonstrated respect for President Clinton, and for the office of the Presidency. 

In his recently released memoir, "A Promised Land," President Obama reflects on his own transition into office from George H.W. Bush's son, George W. Bush. No doubt that President George W. Bush's actions played heavily on President Obama's own actions, welcoming President-Elect Donald Trump to the White House days after the election, and joining him the morning of his Inauguration through President Trump taking the Oath of Office. 

I was also drawn to a passage in George W. Bush's memoir, "Decision Points," in which he discusses the process of end of term Presidential pardons. Specifically, President Bush notes (page 104-105):

"One of the biggest surprises of my presidency was the flood of pardon requests at the end.  I could not believe the number of people who pulled me aside to suggest that a friend or former colleague deserved a pardon.  At first I was frustrated.  Then I was disgusted. I came to see the massive injustice in the system. If you had connections to the president, you could insert your case into the last-minute frenzy.  Otherwise, you had to wait for the Justice Department to conduct a review and make a recommendation.  In my final weeks in office, I resolved that I would not pardon anyone who went outside the formal channels..."

Compare these two aspects of the Presidency, transitions and pardons, to the actions of President Trump. The opposite of welcoming in the man who defeated him, and seeking to help him, President Trump sought to actively undermine him, and even overturn the election through illegal means. Rather than prioritize pardon requests that came through the formal channels of Justice Department review, President Trump prioritized pardons brought to him by those who had access, access which was in some instances perhaps paid for. 

At the end of this reflection, I recommend another book: "The President's Club" by Nancy Gibbs and Michael Duffy. From Truman through to Obama, all Presidents in the modern era played by a similar set of rules after they left office. No doubt President Trump will play by a very different set of rules; he did, after all, do it his way, and has left us no reason to doubt that anything beyond an extension of that train wreck will continue. 

Monday, March 6, 2017

When Politics Collides With Anything

Just a quick post for this Monday. We often hear actors or musicians speak out politically, and the backlash is almost always immediate from whatever side of the aisle they are not supporting. Athletes, however, are often more quiet than their celebrity peers. Not so for Dexter Fowler, recently of the World Series Champion Chicago Cubs (and now, sadly, playing for the St. Louis Cardinals). Fowler was asked about the impact of the Trump Administration's travel ban on his family. He is married to an Iranian woman, so it was a logical question.

It seemed like a fair, reasonable question. He responded, and in doing so seemed to incite  a good portion of his new fan base, which tends to trend pretty conservative. Now, of course we know that the people most likely to comment like that are not representative of all people in a particular demographic. We also know how easy it is to act big and tough behind your keyboard. Trying to be yourself lends itself to being the worst of yourself when nobody can "catch" you. But there is no doubt in my mind that the question was fair, Fowler's response appropriate, and the overarching reaction was not as much fair or appropriate. Simply put, just because someone is an athlete, or a musician, or an actor, doesn't mean that they lose their right to their first amendment privileges. Just because Fowler will be heard in a much broader way than I am doesn't mean that he shouldn't say anything. Freedom of speech is something we all have, regardless of our chosen professions.

Wednesday, February 22, 2017

Trump's Presidency After A Month - Some Quick Hit Thoughts

Reality is a tough thing, and here is reality: I cannot possibly keep up with everything that this Administration is putting down. Not in my life, and certainly not if I attempt to write about all of it. For every one take I post there are at least half a dozen that fall by the wayside. This, of course, is part of the Trump strategy, both throughout the campaign and now into his Administration. Keep the ball constantly moving and don't let anyone (voters, Democrats, Republicans, the media) focus in on any one thing. This also benefits President Trump, as it did candidate Trump, by allowing so much noise that any misstep is quickly forgotten by the next.

And so, today, I introduce the "Quick Hits" post. This is intended to throw you, the reader, some links to articles I've read as I try to keep up with the political cyclone encompassing our country right now. I'll give you some brief analysis for each, but encourage you, as always, to read yourself and determine how what I present fits with your own analysis and worldview.


  • First things first: Trump and his 2/16/17 press conference. To say that there's been nothing like this in presidential history is an understatement. Trump ranted, went on tangents, and continued to bring up non-sequitur arguments with shocking frequency. His fascination with ratings, approval, and meaningless factoids (many of which are not facts, but falsehoods) would be entertaining if it wasn't coming from the Chief Executive of our Government and Commander in Chief of our Military.   
  • The story of Michael Flynn's (likely) illegal pre-inauguration activities, coupled with him lying to the Vice-President, coupled with the Administration knowing about the lies for weeks, not telling the Vice-President about the lies for weeks ... can you see what I mean about this Administration and how hard it is to stay on top of it? This story is still in the news, but has fallen off far quicker than it would have in any other previous Administration. That the Administration seemingly was not going to fire Flynn until it became public knowledge should raise major concerns about the ethical competency of this President and his Administration. Let's just say that there is a ton to unpack in this story, and many good reasons to want to do so. I hope that this is the thing that forces the GOP to stand up, starting with a thorough investigation of this situation, no matter where it may lead. 
  • While President Trump may be saying, to the press, that his Administration is running like a "fine tuned machine," plenty of other information indicates otherwise. With stories that President Trump is looking actively for fall persons within his Administration, and that much of that pressure is falling on Chief of Staff Reince Priebus, it is probably worth noting that Steve Bannon's Alt-Right opinion outlet, Breitbart, is pushing heavily for Priebus to be fired. It doesn't appear that everything is paradise within the West Wing after all, but given Trump's stated goal of creating conflict within his team by pitting people against each other this can't be much of a surprise. 
  • I would encourage you to read this series, from Nate Silver at 538, about the 2016 election. I haven't found a better retrospective/autopsy of what happened in 2016 and what it means moving forward. Recently, Silver talked about the Electoral College blind spot.
  • Finally, a perspective on how ineffectual Trump and his Presidency might prove to be.