Showing posts with label President Biden. Show all posts
Showing posts with label President Biden. Show all posts

Wednesday, January 27, 2021

Transitions, Pardons, and History

 So I have reflected a bit about the completely abnormal nature of the Trump Presidency in the last week. There are certainly no shortage of areas to mine for differences, but two came to mind: transitions and pardons. I am an avid reader of political memoirs and, on Inauguration night there was a video of the three Presidents immediately preceding President Trump which made me think of a few that do a good job putting the Presidency into context. That context, in turn, helps to show just how (dangerously) different the Trump Presidency was. 

The video, which appears to be recorded after the Inauguration ceremony, features Presidents Obama, Bush, and Clinton standing around and talking about the office, and the nature of taking the Oath of Office and becoming President. Watching these three men stand around and discuss the nature of taking that responsibility on made me reflect on a book by Jon Meacham entitled "Destiny and Power". This book, about George H.W. Bush, covers the man's life, including his time in office. It also has a reflection on the letter he wrote Bill Clinton and left in the Oval Office, in which President Bush told the man who had just defeated "your success is now our country's success. I'm rooting for you." 

Compare that to the nearly two and a half months of President Trump refusing to acknowledge that which was obvious: he had lost, and not necessarily closely, to Joe Biden. There is no doubt that George H.W. Bush was disappointed about losing to Bill Clintion. Bush was a man who rushed to enlist in the armed services to fight in World War II, a man who was shot down over the Pacific in combat, and a man who devoted his life to public service. You are not that sort of person, let alone a person who builds a political career that makes the Presidency even a discussion point, without being competitive. Extremely competitive. And yet, "I'm rooting for you." And, more impressively, everything George H.W. Bush did as former President Bush demonstrated respect for President Clinton, and for the office of the Presidency. 

In his recently released memoir, "A Promised Land," President Obama reflects on his own transition into office from George H.W. Bush's son, George W. Bush. No doubt that President George W. Bush's actions played heavily on President Obama's own actions, welcoming President-Elect Donald Trump to the White House days after the election, and joining him the morning of his Inauguration through President Trump taking the Oath of Office. 

I was also drawn to a passage in George W. Bush's memoir, "Decision Points," in which he discusses the process of end of term Presidential pardons. Specifically, President Bush notes (page 104-105):

"One of the biggest surprises of my presidency was the flood of pardon requests at the end.  I could not believe the number of people who pulled me aside to suggest that a friend or former colleague deserved a pardon.  At first I was frustrated.  Then I was disgusted. I came to see the massive injustice in the system. If you had connections to the president, you could insert your case into the last-minute frenzy.  Otherwise, you had to wait for the Justice Department to conduct a review and make a recommendation.  In my final weeks in office, I resolved that I would not pardon anyone who went outside the formal channels..."

Compare these two aspects of the Presidency, transitions and pardons, to the actions of President Trump. The opposite of welcoming in the man who defeated him, and seeking to help him, President Trump sought to actively undermine him, and even overturn the election through illegal means. Rather than prioritize pardon requests that came through the formal channels of Justice Department review, President Trump prioritized pardons brought to him by those who had access, access which was in some instances perhaps paid for. 

At the end of this reflection, I recommend another book: "The President's Club" by Nancy Gibbs and Michael Duffy. From Truman through to Obama, all Presidents in the modern era played by a similar set of rules after they left office. No doubt President Trump will play by a very different set of rules; he did, after all, do it his way, and has left us no reason to doubt that anything beyond an extension of that train wreck will continue. 

Wednesday, January 20, 2021

Are You Ready For 2024?

Politics happens fast, and predictions tend to fall to the wayside even faster. In just the last twelve years the Republican Party has been left for dead by media pundits at least twice. First, after the second term of George W. Bush, which resulted in a landslide election that not only brought President Obama to office but also grew strong majorities in the House and Senate. This election led to James Carville writing a book entitled "40 More Years: How the Democrats Will Rule the Next Generation." Of course, Carville's prediction fell just a bit short; before the book could have a paper back printing in 2011 you had the 2010 midterms, which saw the GOP surge to take back the House, and nearly take back the Senate. 

And here we are again, with analysis wondering where the GOP will go from here, and think pieces declaring the end of the Republican party. This is, of course, not unprecedented in our history (I'm looking at you Whigs), but it is unlikely. That said, I believe it's clear that Trumpism gives the GOP a bigger stumbling block than the end of the Bush administration did. It's important to recognize key factors why that may be:

1. The GOP finds itself torn in two in a way it hasn't in quite some time. The biggest fault line lies squarely over one of the hallowed centerpieces of conservative politics: small government with balanced budgets. While the GOP hasn't actually believed in these things for years*, they've at least been uniform in professing their belief in these things. Now, you have a populist surge within the Republican party, headed by Trump and articulated by individuals like Josh Hawley (Senator from Missouri) that is in alignment on some issues with Bernie Sanders. While the Presidencies of Reagan and George W Bush saw national debt increases north of 100%, they at least stuck to the talking point of small government and balanced spending. Trump didn't, and now the party is openly split between those who truly seem to believe in these ideals and those who openly do not. 

2. Government spending isn't the only place where the GOP finds itself at a crossroads. The merger of the Republican Party with conservative Christians took place over many decades, but crystalized under Karl Rove's leadership during George W Bush's two terms in office. The Presidency of Donald Trump, however, has turned that on its head. Not to say that conservative Christian's are not, by and large, supportive of President Trump. They are; they just have to engage in a lot more mental, ethical and moral gymnastics to get there. This, in turn, has led to some splintering within the "religious right" and GOP coalition. Rove famously pointed out that conservative Christians either vote Republican or they don't vote; George W Bush listened to him where his father didn't, and he ensured that his platform spoke to this group directly. It was an easier sell, however: In Bush you had a born again Christian who genuinely believed what he was saying. In Trump you have the Access Hollywood, multi-divorced, man who has a moral standing that is the anthesis of what Christian conservatives claim to stand for. For many, it was worth it, and the evidence is seen in three names: Gorsuch, Kavanaugh and Coney-Barrett. But, as President Lincoln once sagely put it, a house divided cannot stand. I suspect that the GOP will have a "religious right" problem in the coming years. Some will believe the ends (three conservative, presumably anti-abortion Justices on the Supreme Court) will justify the means, and they will continue to support. Others will say "we got what we wanted, now I'm not going to vote." But regardless the Christian conservatives in this country will face an internal reckoning centered around the hypocrisy of supporting Donald Trump, a man who has very often stood in opposition to Christian principles. Or at least they should. 

3. Finally, the Trump Administration led to a third dividing line between the GOP of old and the new order: foreign policy. The coalition of Nixon, Reagan and both Presidents Bush was built on a strong, hawkish US foreign policy. We arm up, we demonstrate power globally, and we fight wars (early and often if possible). President Trump spun this on its' head, seeking to withdraw from international coalitions and agreements, ceding power and influence to China, Russia, and others, and looking to take the US to a more isolationist position**. Again, this is not without precedent (Wilson and FDR were isolationist ahead of the World Wars until they were not), but it is unprecedented in the modern (post WWII) era. What makes it particularly unprecedented is that, under President Trump, the GOP went from being uniformly dominated by hawks to housing portions more dovish than the vast majority of anti-interventionist Democrats. 

Taken in total, these three balancing acts (size of government and spending, conservative Christian values, and foreign policy) seem poised to drive the discussion in the build up to 2024, and the Republican primaries. Of course, the success, or lack thereof, of the Biden administration will play a huge role in the GOP nominating process, as will the outcome of the 2022 midterm elections. The Democrats managed to win the White House in 2020, lose seats in the House, and gain seats in the Senate; all told, it was an atypical election year.

Prognosticating this far out is a fraught exercise, but there is reason to believe that the Republicans may take back the House in 2022, while losing another seat or two in the Senate. Imagine, for a moment, that outcome, and couple it with another reasonable outcome: after the 2022 midterm election President Biden announces he will take the James K. Polk route and only serve a single term, declining to run for re-election. Vice President Harris becomes a leading candidate, but certainly not a shoe in (most likely). It is in that unique (albeit imaginary at this point) environment that the Republican Primary in 2024 may take place. 

So the Democrats would have the establishment (Harris would likely have a chance to clear this portion of the field unless the Administration is in disarray) face off against the far left (hard to tell this far out, but think AOC or someone of that type of stature). The Republicans, conversely, would have an interparty war between more establishment, traditional members (Ben Sasse, Nikki Haley probably, perhaps John Kasich or Larry Hogan), members trying to straddle the line between Trumpism and the traditional GOP (looking at you Mike Pence, but also Tom Cotton), and those who are fully trying to inherit the championship belt from Trump and declare Trumpism as the new GOP platform (Josh Hawley, maybe Ted Cruz, and yes, quite possibly a Trump - either the 45th President himself looking for a Cleveland like comeback, or Donald Trump Jr.). 

It's hard to say who has an advantage in that scenario this far out. At this moment it would seem that Ben Sasse, or those like him, have the inside track given how divided the GOP appears to be. Mike Pence seems to be damaged goods, but a book tour and time on cable news can repair some of that. Hawley and Cruz, to say nothing of the Trumps, seem on the verge of being ostracized at present, but that can swing around quickly to cult hero status. The reality is that the next two years will be crucial in this process. Who will have the largest voice in the minority government. Already, the battle lines are drawn: you're either with Trump (Jim Jordan) or you're the enemy and need to be stripped of all influence (Liz Cheney). Only a Sith deals in absolutes? Try telling that to Trump and his acolytes. The GOP has become a zero sum game all unto itself. I will be paying the closest attention to members who try to have it both ways. It is an unlikely gambit, fraught with pitfalls on both sides, but if a charismatic enough politician can simultaneously claim to be the heir to Reagan and Trump ... well, that person will be a strong candidate in 2024, regardless of what the Biden Administration does, regardless of who is running at the top of the Democratic ticket. The race to 2024 may have informally started, but it officially begins today. Hope you're ready. 


*The reigning champion for adding to the national debt remains FDR (and, with a nearly 1,050% increase - yes you read that right - FDR will likely never be topped). But After FDR (the Great Depression and WWII) and Woodrow Wilson (WWI) the next highest increases to the debt by percentage are Reagan (186%) and George W Bush (101%). Obama will stay ahead of Trump, but only due to having served two terms to Trump's one; at the end of one term the debt's growth under Trump exceeds the growth under Obama, who was dealing with the great recession at the time.

**This, in turn, has left the Biden Administration a far more dangerous North Korea and Iran, for example, than the Trump Administration was left by the Obama Administration. 

Thursday, January 14, 2021

Will We Not Survive Ourselves?

 "We crossed the oceans wide, built cities to the sky oh lord. Looked up and we were flying. But will we not survive ourselves?" - Dave Matthew Band, Gaucho

This lyric stuck in my head over the last week as I read numerous think pieces regarding President Trump and his need to either A) resign the Presidency, B) have his powers removed by his Cabinet and Vice President via the 25th Amendment, or C) be Impeached and tried. I am not going to write thousands of words on this (although I could), but I did want to jump on to lay out a few points about why it is important to have a check on Presidential power, and the significant risk we find ourselves in as a country and civilization.

I suspect most people have never heard of James Schlesinger. He was the Secretary of Defense under President Nixon, a man who took an action that can simultaneously be celebrated and condemned - and neither side would be wrong. In 1974 President Nixon was nearing resignation, and was, by all accounts, not well mentally. He was drinking to excess, and scheming ways to stay in power. He was even reported to have joked about dropping a nuclear bomb on Capitol Hill as Congress moved to impeach him. This nuclear fantasy wasn't isolated; he also is reported to have made a point of saying "I can go into my office and pick up the telephone, and in 25 minutes 70 million people will be dead."  

Secretary Schlesinger helped to make that not possible, as he separated the nuclear codes from President Nixon, further insisting that any order to launch be cleared by him or National Security Advisor Henry Kissinger first. Many of the things that led to Secretary Schlesinger's unprecedented action in 1974 are present today: a damaged, mentally unwell President scheming for ways to stay in power, desperate and fearing for his own legal liability. Secretary Schlesinger acted in a way that could accurately be described as simultaneously patriotic and mutinous. He acted to save the world, while also undermining the chain of command to his Commander in Chief. This article, entitled "The Most Patriotic Act of Treason in American History" sums it up well, just in the title. (If you're interested in learning more about this period of time, including Nixon, the nuclear codes, and the relevance to this discussion today, check out this article.)

There is no doubt in my mind that President Trump hoped that the violent insurrection on January 6th, 2021 would lead to him staying in power. Foreign policy experts like Fiona Hill and Timothy Snyder have given detailed explanations about why this was, in fact, a coup attempt, and how Trump's actions closely align with failed dictators, but didn't deviate too far from those of successful dictators. I won't rehash their well researched, well reasoned articles here. I will strongly encourage you to read them for context to this entire discussion. Those who would say that President Trump didn't attempt a coup, didn't attempt to move us towards an authoritarian dictatorship, and didn't directly seek to undermine democracy in our country are simply lying: either to themselves, or to you. He did, and in that context, we need to revisit Secretary Schlesinger's actions in the context of 2021 and beyond. 

Joe Cirincione is one of the leading minds in the area of nuclear non-proliferation. His book, Deadly Arsenals: Nuclear, Biological and Chemical Threats was a key resources in my education in international relations. The book opens with this statement:

"The proliferation of nuclear, biological, and chemical weapons is widely recognized as the most serious threat to the national security of the United States and other nations." 

In the 15 plus years since the second edition of this book was published, the only thing that I would add is that climate change has probably wedged itself in there on equal footing. That said, the nuclear age undoubtedly brought challenges, and we face those challenges still today. Cirincione is one of the most established and respected minds in foreign policy when it comes to nuclear non-proliferation, nuclear security/diplomacy, and weapons systems (including their realistic use and limitations). He writes for Responsible Statecraft these days, and it is his most recent article, from January 13, 2021, that I want to end by reflecting on. 

Cirincione opens by reflecting on Speaker Pelosi's concerns about President Trump, in his closing days, being unfit to have nuclear launch capability at his disposal. Of course, if you followed the news you know that Speaker Pelosi says she was assured by the Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, General Milley, that there were checks in place to stop the President from acting on any impulse to start a war (most likely, Cirincinoe correctly points out, with Iran; my concerns here could fill another post). Of course, if General Milley or any other military member ignored the President's direct order, they would be violating their chain of command, which would be mutiny.

Cirincione explains, in readily accessible detail, the reason that the system is set up as it is (for the President to be able to authorize a nuclear strike by himself without secondary approval). Cirincione also explains why that needs to change, and then suggests how to do it: 

"It must be at the top of Joe Biden's agenda to change the obsolete policies that make this nightmare scenario possible. One, end the first-strike policy so that any order to fire nuclear weapons first is illegal. Two, take weapons off high alert so that they cannot be launched in minutes, allowing more time for deliberation and reconsideration of launch orders. Three, end the sole authority of any president to start a nuclear way by requiring at the top what we require all the rest of the way down the launch chain: two must agree to launch." 

This makes good sense. If nuclear weapons are to be a meaningful deterrent (and I am of the mindset that they are), then we should make it clear they are a deterrent, not a first strike option. This would not limit our ability, as a nation, to defend ourselves, nor would it limit our ability to respond to nuclear aggression in kind. It would simply reduce the likelihood of a desperate or unwell politician at the top of the launch command making a mistake for which all of civilization will pay. 

Of particular note, Cirincione ends by explaining that many of these actions Biden can take immediately upon taking office, through executive orders. Other actions, such as treaties for arms reduction both alone and in concert with other nations, require Congressional approval. But it is long past time for us to stop celebrating what Secretary Schlesinger did, to stop putting our hope in what General Milley says he would do, and instead recognize that putting our military or civilian servants in the position of having to engage in a mutinous action to save the world is unacceptable. 

This week has shown that these actions are all the more important, given the extreme polarization in our country that makes it so A) the President won't resign because there isn't a critical mass of Republicans calling for it, B) the Cabinet and Vice President won't act because they see it as giving in to the other side, and C) the Senate might convict, or it might not, but they won't act quickly in any event. Our political polarization has led us to a moment where most Americans, and even most in Congress, are in agreement that the President is too unsafe to have a Twitter account, but we cannot act uniformly to remove him from the nuclear codes without banking on someone engaging in mutiny to do it. That's dumb policy, and it has to change.