Showing posts with label Foreign Policy. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Foreign Policy. Show all posts

Thursday, January 14, 2021

Will We Not Survive Ourselves?

 "We crossed the oceans wide, built cities to the sky oh lord. Looked up and we were flying. But will we not survive ourselves?" - Dave Matthew Band, Gaucho

This lyric stuck in my head over the last week as I read numerous think pieces regarding President Trump and his need to either A) resign the Presidency, B) have his powers removed by his Cabinet and Vice President via the 25th Amendment, or C) be Impeached and tried. I am not going to write thousands of words on this (although I could), but I did want to jump on to lay out a few points about why it is important to have a check on Presidential power, and the significant risk we find ourselves in as a country and civilization.

I suspect most people have never heard of James Schlesinger. He was the Secretary of Defense under President Nixon, a man who took an action that can simultaneously be celebrated and condemned - and neither side would be wrong. In 1974 President Nixon was nearing resignation, and was, by all accounts, not well mentally. He was drinking to excess, and scheming ways to stay in power. He was even reported to have joked about dropping a nuclear bomb on Capitol Hill as Congress moved to impeach him. This nuclear fantasy wasn't isolated; he also is reported to have made a point of saying "I can go into my office and pick up the telephone, and in 25 minutes 70 million people will be dead."  

Secretary Schlesinger helped to make that not possible, as he separated the nuclear codes from President Nixon, further insisting that any order to launch be cleared by him or National Security Advisor Henry Kissinger first. Many of the things that led to Secretary Schlesinger's unprecedented action in 1974 are present today: a damaged, mentally unwell President scheming for ways to stay in power, desperate and fearing for his own legal liability. Secretary Schlesinger acted in a way that could accurately be described as simultaneously patriotic and mutinous. He acted to save the world, while also undermining the chain of command to his Commander in Chief. This article, entitled "The Most Patriotic Act of Treason in American History" sums it up well, just in the title. (If you're interested in learning more about this period of time, including Nixon, the nuclear codes, and the relevance to this discussion today, check out this article.)

There is no doubt in my mind that President Trump hoped that the violent insurrection on January 6th, 2021 would lead to him staying in power. Foreign policy experts like Fiona Hill and Timothy Snyder have given detailed explanations about why this was, in fact, a coup attempt, and how Trump's actions closely align with failed dictators, but didn't deviate too far from those of successful dictators. I won't rehash their well researched, well reasoned articles here. I will strongly encourage you to read them for context to this entire discussion. Those who would say that President Trump didn't attempt a coup, didn't attempt to move us towards an authoritarian dictatorship, and didn't directly seek to undermine democracy in our country are simply lying: either to themselves, or to you. He did, and in that context, we need to revisit Secretary Schlesinger's actions in the context of 2021 and beyond. 

Joe Cirincione is one of the leading minds in the area of nuclear non-proliferation. His book, Deadly Arsenals: Nuclear, Biological and Chemical Threats was a key resources in my education in international relations. The book opens with this statement:

"The proliferation of nuclear, biological, and chemical weapons is widely recognized as the most serious threat to the national security of the United States and other nations." 

In the 15 plus years since the second edition of this book was published, the only thing that I would add is that climate change has probably wedged itself in there on equal footing. That said, the nuclear age undoubtedly brought challenges, and we face those challenges still today. Cirincione is one of the most established and respected minds in foreign policy when it comes to nuclear non-proliferation, nuclear security/diplomacy, and weapons systems (including their realistic use and limitations). He writes for Responsible Statecraft these days, and it is his most recent article, from January 13, 2021, that I want to end by reflecting on. 

Cirincione opens by reflecting on Speaker Pelosi's concerns about President Trump, in his closing days, being unfit to have nuclear launch capability at his disposal. Of course, if you followed the news you know that Speaker Pelosi says she was assured by the Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, General Milley, that there were checks in place to stop the President from acting on any impulse to start a war (most likely, Cirincinoe correctly points out, with Iran; my concerns here could fill another post). Of course, if General Milley or any other military member ignored the President's direct order, they would be violating their chain of command, which would be mutiny.

Cirincione explains, in readily accessible detail, the reason that the system is set up as it is (for the President to be able to authorize a nuclear strike by himself without secondary approval). Cirincione also explains why that needs to change, and then suggests how to do it: 

"It must be at the top of Joe Biden's agenda to change the obsolete policies that make this nightmare scenario possible. One, end the first-strike policy so that any order to fire nuclear weapons first is illegal. Two, take weapons off high alert so that they cannot be launched in minutes, allowing more time for deliberation and reconsideration of launch orders. Three, end the sole authority of any president to start a nuclear way by requiring at the top what we require all the rest of the way down the launch chain: two must agree to launch." 

This makes good sense. If nuclear weapons are to be a meaningful deterrent (and I am of the mindset that they are), then we should make it clear they are a deterrent, not a first strike option. This would not limit our ability, as a nation, to defend ourselves, nor would it limit our ability to respond to nuclear aggression in kind. It would simply reduce the likelihood of a desperate or unwell politician at the top of the launch command making a mistake for which all of civilization will pay. 

Of particular note, Cirincione ends by explaining that many of these actions Biden can take immediately upon taking office, through executive orders. Other actions, such as treaties for arms reduction both alone and in concert with other nations, require Congressional approval. But it is long past time for us to stop celebrating what Secretary Schlesinger did, to stop putting our hope in what General Milley says he would do, and instead recognize that putting our military or civilian servants in the position of having to engage in a mutinous action to save the world is unacceptable. 

This week has shown that these actions are all the more important, given the extreme polarization in our country that makes it so A) the President won't resign because there isn't a critical mass of Republicans calling for it, B) the Cabinet and Vice President won't act because they see it as giving in to the other side, and C) the Senate might convict, or it might not, but they won't act quickly in any event. Our political polarization has led us to a moment where most Americans, and even most in Congress, are in agreement that the President is too unsafe to have a Twitter account, but we cannot act uniformly to remove him from the nuclear codes without banking on someone engaging in mutiny to do it. That's dumb policy, and it has to change. 

Wednesday, April 12, 2017

The Incompetent Presidency

I know that President Trump, his administration, and his die hard supporters will just scream "fake news," but can't help but be somewhat stunned when a well established conservative publication like The National Review publishes something like this article. I suppose, however, that it is unavoidable due to the complete ineptitude displayed by the Trump Administration nearly three months into assuming the office.

The first 100 days is typically a time where a new administration passes a good many new initiatives, strengthened by the political capital and "mandate" stemming from the election. In the case where the President has entered office without a resounding mandate, such as the 2000 election and George W. Bush, the administration has typically worked aggressively with the other party to achieve bipartisan legislative achievements. These are the two options, historically and for good reason: if you have the capital you should use it before circumstances dictate that you lose it. If you don't have the capital, working with the other side can garner respect and support in the event that you gain it in the future.

The Trump Administration, inexplicably, has seemingly settled on a third option: go to war with everyone. Accordingly, it seems likely at this point that they will end their first 100 days without a single headline achievement on which to rest their hats. The buildup to the midterm election will be fast and furious this time around, similar to what was observed in 1994 or 2010. An Administration without a mandate (no President in modern times has had less of a mandate than President Trump did upon taking the oath of office) has decided to try to operate by strong arming people. He has served to stir up the opposition to the point where they are apparently poised to oppose nearly everything. He has also served to further fracture his own party, splitting off extreme and moderate portions of his party already.

In sum, it is inarguable at this point that this administration is ill equipped for the responsibility of governing. With issues spiraling out of control in the realm of foreign policy (Syria and North Korea most disconcertingly), and with their own administration in the line of fire for a series of apparent lies told by campaign and administration personnel regarding their own involvement with Russia, as well as the President's own inability to stay out of his own way on social media, it seems simultaneously essential that the administration somehow rush through their own steep learning curve and catastrophically impossible that they can learn at all. Three months in things look bad. They are poised to look a lot worse in three months if there isn't a miraculous turnaround hidden just out of sight.

Wednesday, March 8, 2017

A New Cold War? One New Yorker Article Hypothesizes As Much

This article, posted in the New Yorker, takes a deep dive into the world of foreign relations as it relates to the United States and Russia. The article is certainly an interesting take to consider. I would implore people out there to take in information like this, and to consider what it might mean moving forward. The far right media will cry foul throughout this process, accusing the process of "media bias" or being "fake news," but in reality there is much more meat on the bones than they'd want to admit.

The interesting thing about this current Administration's (mostly) overt pro-Russian bent is how counter it runs to the general GOP's recent approach to Russia. Using history as a lens through which to view current relations between the countries is not only practical, but a proven method for trying to decode international relations and what's likely to happen going forward. The same rationale applies to looking at the fall of democracies and empires past when looking at our own governmental institutions. Doing so isn't the same as saying those things will happen, but simply indicates that the possibility is always there, and being aware of what things were antecedents in the past might help to avoid a similar fate in the present.

In sum, I'd encourage you to read the article linked above, regardless of your viewpoint. It doesn't hurt to broaden our horizons and consider possible outcomes, no matter how plausible we individually believe they might be. After all, I doubt too many Romans foresaw the fall of Rome in the way it ultimately happened, nor did citizens of the British Empire at the turn of the 20th century. Time is relentless, and, as the saying goes, those ignorant of history are bound to repeat it.

Wednesday, February 22, 2017

Trump's Presidency After A Month - Some Quick Hit Thoughts

Reality is a tough thing, and here is reality: I cannot possibly keep up with everything that this Administration is putting down. Not in my life, and certainly not if I attempt to write about all of it. For every one take I post there are at least half a dozen that fall by the wayside. This, of course, is part of the Trump strategy, both throughout the campaign and now into his Administration. Keep the ball constantly moving and don't let anyone (voters, Democrats, Republicans, the media) focus in on any one thing. This also benefits President Trump, as it did candidate Trump, by allowing so much noise that any misstep is quickly forgotten by the next.

And so, today, I introduce the "Quick Hits" post. This is intended to throw you, the reader, some links to articles I've read as I try to keep up with the political cyclone encompassing our country right now. I'll give you some brief analysis for each, but encourage you, as always, to read yourself and determine how what I present fits with your own analysis and worldview.


  • First things first: Trump and his 2/16/17 press conference. To say that there's been nothing like this in presidential history is an understatement. Trump ranted, went on tangents, and continued to bring up non-sequitur arguments with shocking frequency. His fascination with ratings, approval, and meaningless factoids (many of which are not facts, but falsehoods) would be entertaining if it wasn't coming from the Chief Executive of our Government and Commander in Chief of our Military.   
  • The story of Michael Flynn's (likely) illegal pre-inauguration activities, coupled with him lying to the Vice-President, coupled with the Administration knowing about the lies for weeks, not telling the Vice-President about the lies for weeks ... can you see what I mean about this Administration and how hard it is to stay on top of it? This story is still in the news, but has fallen off far quicker than it would have in any other previous Administration. That the Administration seemingly was not going to fire Flynn until it became public knowledge should raise major concerns about the ethical competency of this President and his Administration. Let's just say that there is a ton to unpack in this story, and many good reasons to want to do so. I hope that this is the thing that forces the GOP to stand up, starting with a thorough investigation of this situation, no matter where it may lead. 
  • While President Trump may be saying, to the press, that his Administration is running like a "fine tuned machine," plenty of other information indicates otherwise. With stories that President Trump is looking actively for fall persons within his Administration, and that much of that pressure is falling on Chief of Staff Reince Priebus, it is probably worth noting that Steve Bannon's Alt-Right opinion outlet, Breitbart, is pushing heavily for Priebus to be fired. It doesn't appear that everything is paradise within the West Wing after all, but given Trump's stated goal of creating conflict within his team by pitting people against each other this can't be much of a surprise. 
  • I would encourage you to read this series, from Nate Silver at 538, about the 2016 election. I haven't found a better retrospective/autopsy of what happened in 2016 and what it means moving forward. Recently, Silver talked about the Electoral College blind spot.
  • Finally, a perspective on how ineffectual Trump and his Presidency might prove to be. 

Monday, February 20, 2017

Checks and Balances

Then candidate Trump made a big deal throughout the presidential campaign about how he was not a politician. He said this with pride, talking about how he would "drain the swamp" and how he knew how to "get things done." Central to his entire campaign, then, was the promise that he would simultaneously not be a part of the Washington establishment while knowing how to do the job from day one.

Of course, where else do we see this type of marketing of oneself for a job? I couldn't walk into the prestigious Mayo Clinic and argue that I deserved a job as a surgeon because I was good at my current job and was not a surgical insider. Setting aside for a moment the legitimate questions regarding just how good Donald Trump was at his "job" before winning the Presidency, think back to this point: Trump said he was the right person for the job because he had no experience for the job.

Now imagine that the Mayo Clinic hires me as a surgeon. I come in, I scrub up, I go into the operating room. And then it hits me: it doesn't matter how good I was or wasn't in my old job, nor does it matter how good I was at selling the Mayo hiring team on me. Now I actually need to know how to do this. In other words, I'm probably in big trouble in this situation.

Name one profession besides politician in which there is such a fascination with putting inexperienced outsiders into key roles? There is typically a reason that people stay in politics beyond the self-serving, power hungry ones: they become good at what they do, and they like doing it, so they stay. That is not all together different than why I stay in my current career. But Trump did something that hasn't been done in our nation's history. It wasn't that he sold the outsider story managed to win the whole thing; Andrew Jackson did that back in the 1800s.

No, what Trump did was manage to actually be a functional outsider, in as much as he had no experience with politics or the political process. He then doubled down, putting an inexperienced administration around him in key positions, including much of his cabinet. So it can't really be that much of a surprise that Trump would roll out an Executive Order at some point that would be challenged successfully in the courts. What made the order that accomplished this so special is that, in many ways, the scope of what Trump was trying to do had been established as constitutional in the past. But a poor roll out, due to not preparing anyone in his Administration for the order, led to a hold in court. What happened next was particularly stunning to the system, if not at all surprising to those who have paid attention to Donald Trump throughout his career: President Trump attacked the Judiciary with reckless abandon.

Trump's actions almost assuredly helped to nudge the 9th circuit to unanimously decide against his Administration's appeal. Trump then vowed to fight on, in all CAPS, but predictably this was little more than hot air. At present it seems likely that his Administration will  regroup, tail between their legs, and try to issue a more well thought out Executive Order on immigration next week. Of course, they will try to sell this not as a regrouping or retreat of any measure, and will instead try to spin this in some way attacking the "enemy." In this case, the court, as Trump has continued to do, most recently in his 80 minute marathon press conference on February 16th.

The upshot of this approach, however, is that it will only serve to further irritate the Courts at every level of this country. If the Trump Administration had played it cool it is possible that they might have won a stay, or at least a full appeal, at the 9th circuit. Furthermore, it was likely that the Supreme Court would have ruled in his Administration's favor, once Neil Gorsuch is confirmed (news flash: that's happening barring a huge surprise). I suspect strongly, however, that Trump's actions will have influenced Anthony Kennedy strongly, leading the "swing" vote on the court to be more likely to view the Trump Administration critically. Even beyond that, it is possible that the same thing has happened to John Roberts, the Chief Justice. If that is the case it is possible that even with Gorsuch, the Trump Administration may only have two other "safe" votes on their side: Justice Thomas and Justice Alito.

If that's the case, then the Trump Administration may be in for a rude awakening in the coming years, particularly if they continue to push a far right agenda rather than trying to trend towards the center. The more Trump complains about one third of our government structure the more likely it is that he will have conflict. And, thus far, President Trump seems no less likely to bash someone who upsets him than candidate Trump was. His attempts to discredit key American institutions, such as free press and the Courts, should be disconcerting to say the least to anyone invested in this country. For anyone who wants to see this country's democracy continue on, at least the way it was intended, the checks and balances are going to be more crucial than ever moving forward. The press, presenting information to the general public, and the Courts, evaluating the Administration's agenda, will be two critical aspects of this. President Trump and his Administration may have lost their first run in with the judicial system; smart money says it will not be his last.

Wednesday, February 8, 2017

On NAFTA, The Border, and Trade Wars

One of then candidate Trump's biggest pledges was to take on Mexico on many fronts, and for many purposes. Within his first two weeks in office he has put the wheels in motion to do just that, and in a number of ways. Trump has floated the idea of a 20% tax on imported goods, is pushing to "build that wall" even though it looks like it will amount to a huge bill for the American tax payers to pick up, and has done more to damage diplomatic relations with our southern neighbor than at any time since we were actively trying to take over their territory.

As Mark Cuban says here, much of the Trump Administration's apparent "strategy" would amount to high costs being passed on to the American consumer. Furthermore, team Trump is blatantly moving forward with an aggressive agenda centered on tax cuts and spending increases, a plan which is poised to make the budget deficits of the Bush 43 and Obama years look like child's play at best. While the short term ramifications of that approach would almost assuredly lead to increased jobs, wages, and buying power, the long term outcomes would be higher inflation, higher national debt, and more economic weakness within the country.

At a time when the Trump team is silencing the executive branch from speaking outwardly, and when prominent GOP Senators are reporting they are unable to get answers themselves, citizens who are trying to stay informed are more and more realizing that they are having to read the tea leaves. For all of the seemingly positive movement of the Dow going up, and of Carrier and Ford keeping jobs here, there has been little substantive good news on the business front in the first two plus weeks of this Administration. In fact, the more controversial of Trump's moves have led to backlash from business leaders. While some analysis can show a bit of logic to what Trump's team is trying, it is hard to see a clear picture at this time.

For example, consider what might happen if Trump rips up NAFTA, puts a border tariff in place, and starts building the wall which would be pointless in many areas. We know that companies have pulled planned factories from Mexico already; it is easy to imagine that other factories which are already operating south of the border would board up relatively quickly in this scenario. Those businesses would either A) cease to exist, or B) come back to the US. Great, right? Well, take the future of small cars if all car manufacturing comes back to the US. It's highly unlikely that Ford would invest in plants in the US to build the Ford Focus, given the limited profit margins in that product. Cheap labor makes it possible; expensive labor makes it less attractive or even feasible.

From there it isn't hard to see additional fall out: less selection on the market makes cars more expensive. More cars are big gas guzzlers, which have much larger profit margins, making our dependence on oil greater. Prices very well could go up there as well. More oil usage impacts the environment negatively. It makes US involvement in war in the Middle East much more likely moving forward. But let's say it goes the other way and the car industry determines that we still need those small cars. What is more likely is that they will invest heavily in technology infrastructure to eliminate the reliance on cheap labor by replacing it with robots and computers. That also doesn't help create jobs, at least not the blue collar jobs that Trump promises.

Then there is the impact on our friends to the south in Mexico. Who cares, right? Well, consider the impact that losing those jobs might have. People need to have money, and without jobs they are left with two real options: join cartels and gangs to get money illegally, or illegally get into the USA to work off the books at a lower wage. One option increases the drug flow and violence, the other increases illegal immigration. So we have to fight increases in those things, which leads to even further increased government spending on DEA agents, border agents, and maintenance work to repair and maintain whatever border defenses you have (which are, inevitably, damaged with frequency). And all of this is to say nothing of the increased issues in human rights, quality of life, and other moral and ethical things that could happen in Mexico in this scenario.

All of this is to say that it is highly unlikely that President Trump's stated fantasy of pulling out of NAFTA, implementing a draconian tariff, and building a wall will lead to increased jobs, wages, and security in the USA. Quite the opposite, his concoction of isolationism, xenophobia, and pre-World War II economic policies would likely contribute to raising inflation, wage stagnation, and a functional loss in jobs. I didn't even get into the damage to the Texas economy if NAFTA is killed, among a myriad of other issues if this course of action is taken. The overarching danger, of course, is that in the short term some of his policies could lead to increased wages, increased jobs, and so people won't think of the long term ramifications of the policy. Accordingly, it is very crucial that we pay close attention to the policy as well as the short and long term outcomes which are probable. After all, if President Trump truly wanted to hit the Mexican cartels where it hurts, as he's claimed before, he might give greater consideration to legalizing marijuana.

Monday, January 30, 2017

Sanctuary Cities - Governing is Hard Work!

The term Sanctuary Cities has been in the news intermittently over the last few years, often with people having different understandings of what these cities actually are doing. Within his first week President Trump's Administration issued an executive order to push so called "sanctuary cities" to follow federal orders for detaining illegal immigrants. Shortly after the order was released many of these cities, like Chicago, responded, saying they wouldn't be following the orders.

The big challenge with an order like this is determining who has the responsibility, and who has the authority. The fundamental issue in question is whether these cities will follow Federal orders to detain illegal immigrants who have not committed any other crime outside of being in the country illegally. Opponents of the order argue that such a detainment is unconstitutional in many cases, and that they want to be on the side of constitutionally appropriate actions. Proponents of the order argue that to ignore federal immigration orders to detain illegal immigrants is equally problematic. Miami's Mayor already reversed the city's previous course, ordering local law enforcement to comply with federal detainment orders. Other major city Mayors, such as Rahm Emmanuel in Chicago, quickly responded by saying they would not follow through with the orders.

What President Trump has threatened, through his administration, is that the government would withhold federal funds from any city which fails to comply with the order. An initial review of the money that goes to the jurisdictions targeted by the Trump Administration shows that over 60% of the targeted funding goes to ten places, including California, Cook County Illinois, and the aforementioned Miami-Dade County. It is relatively easy to see that any substantial withholding of federal funds for these areas could quickly become problematic; one only needs to look at the way that the risk of losing federal funds in the past has driven states to a uniform drinking age and to federally approved maximum speed limits. Money drives everything, and the Federal Government's funds make most local and state jurisdictions run. We like to say that we give power to the states, but in spite of the 10th Amendment to the Constitution the Federal Government carries a big stick in terms of funding, and historically it has been willing to use it liberally. 

A major question which has been raised in the aftermath of the Executive Order related to detaining illegal immigrants: who is responsible for paying for the care of individuals who are detained in this way? Miami's Mayor has raised the stakes, calling on the Trump Administration to fund his city's enforcement of Federal requests. Based on early responses it doesn't appear to me that the Trump Administration has given this order, or the ramifications of the order, full thought. The Administration seems fixated on pushing out orders which in some way, shape or form fulfill his many campaign promises, but in many of these instances there appears to have been little to no clear thought given to how to implement the orders, or what the latent consequences of these orders would be. The recent drama centering around NAFTA, "the wall" and Mexico is one clear example of campaign rhetoric running head first into the complexities of governing. Another example was seen across days eight and nine in office, in response to his order halting admission into the US from seven Muslim majority countries. That order was quickly halted while the judiciary was able to look more fully into it, but the spill out of the order was exacerbated by a great deal of confusion as to what it meant, and how it was to be enforced. At a minimum it made the Administration appear unprepared and struggling to determine how to lead. At worst, for his Administration, it provided an early flash point for a diverse base that could lead an opposition movement to rally to. 

At this point it is far too early to pass any uniform judgement on how this Administration will govern, or what their true motives are. That said, it doesn't feel like much of a reach to look at the level of chaos and confusion which has followed many of these early orders and come to the conclusion that there are two leading possibilities. The first is that the Administration will learn from these early stumbles and will start to be more deliberate in designing these orders with planning for how they will roll out. The second is that this Administration, with its complete dearth of governing experience, will continue to allow these follies to permeate everything they do. The latter possibility, when coupled with President Trump's extremely well established thin skin, need to be "right," and impulsiveness, leads to a wealth of scary possibilities. There is a small rumbling within the GOP which indicates to me that some Republicans may fear this exact scenario. Time will tell if they develop the backbone to stand up to the Trump Administration, or if they will need things to get much worse before they do so in an attempt to save themselves, much like their historical predecessors did during the Nixon Administration.