Showing posts with label 2018 Midterms. Show all posts
Showing posts with label 2018 Midterms. Show all posts

Wednesday, March 1, 2017

Trump's Approval Ratings - How Can We Tell, What Do They Mean?

President Trump and his team have done a brilliant job of discrediting the media, even when the very thing they are discrediting is not accurate. For instance, take the polls. President Trump has mentioned many times how "off" the polls were when, in fact, they were more accurate than they were in 2012's Presidential Election. But, since they were just off enough in a handful of critical states, President Trump can bring this up again and again and his supporters will tend to agree blindly.

That pivots, nicely, into a discussion of the President's approval rating. We've already established that Donald Trump is the least popular President upon first term inauguration; President Trump now has another marker in this regard, as he has the lowest approval rating after one month in history, nearly 13 points lower than the prior record holder, Bill Clinton. The question, however, is are these polls "accurate?". Put another way, as Politico does in this article, "Donald Trump might be more popular than you think." Politico breaks down different ways in which Trump might be more popular than traditional metrics measure, and they use the polling error in the general election as one example of how this can happen. 

Nate Silver's crew at 538 offer a different perspective, centered on what Trump's approval ratings mean for the GOP at large in the 2018 Midterm Elections. To get to that discussion the article doesn't dispute that the polls are saying different things, ranging from "approve of his job performance more than disapprove" to "underwater by anywhere from 7 percentage points ... to 15 points." The article then quiets all the noise by rightly pointing out that regardless of where on this spectrum Trump's approval actually lies doesn't matter: he is historically unpopular for a president within his first month. 

As to what that means moving forward for President Trump, his Administration, or the GOP, it is really anyone's guess. It is possible that Trump's approval jumps up very high; look at George W Bush's approval post 9/11/01, or his father's post Desert Storm for one way that could happen. But the chaos inside the White House seems, at this point, to make that jump unlikely at best. Furthermore, almost all Presidents during the modern age have gotten more unpopular as their first term progresses. The exception to that rule? George W Bush, who got a net of 2 points more popular. If President Trump doesn't manage to buck that trend, things could get really ugly, really fast, for the GOP. 

At any rate, this bears much more watching than usual, for two reasons. The first is that it is evident that the pollsters will be working hard to try to prove that they not only have an important role, but are accurate. The second is how much attention Trump pays to the polls. We know already that if a poll comes out that looks good for him he will trumpet it; if a poll comes out he doesn't like he will slam it. But one thing that is certain is that the general public's opinion of the President is a historically important factor in Midterm Elections. Will 2018 be any different?

Wednesday, February 15, 2017

Playing Poker With The G.O.P.

Let's start here: the Republicans who have been in Washington DC for the last number of years are better poker players than we are. They certainly are better poker players than their Democratic counter parts. You can see that through the maneuvers that everyone bemoans as too high risk, only they haven't blown up in their face. Stare down the debt ceiling? Threaten to shut down the government? Come on, that's child's play to the GOP. They are better at this than the Democrats, and until the Democrats start to get better at it they are in real trouble.

Doyle Brunson is one of the most legendary poker players of all time. Brunson is famous for many things, including being a multi-time winner of the prestigious World Series of Poker. One quote from Brunson regarding how to play no-limit Texas Hold'em is particularly prescient as it relates to the GOP's strategy in Washington. Brunson says that "the key to no limit ... is to put a man to a decision for all his chips." In layman's terms, what Brunson is saying here is that the aggressor has the edge, because the other person is always reacting, rather than acting. It takes away their ability to play their own hand, and makes them play your hand. Of course, even the best really don't know with certainty what you have in your hand. That's why it works. And that's what the GOP has been doing to the Democrats for many years. The Democrats respond to the GOP, and they have no idea if they are bluffing or not. 

In this recent article, Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell states that the Democrats must give recent Trump Supreme Court Nominee Neil Gorsuch "an up and down vote," and that failure to do so would be only "to hurt Trump." He accuses the Democrats of playing politics, and essentially says they need to get over losing the election. But here's the beauty of McConnell's statement: he is accusing Democrats of hypothetically doing the very heinous, undemocratic thing ... that McConnell and his Republican counter parts did for almost all of 2016. Remember Merrick Garland? President Obama nominated him last March, and almost instantaneously the Republican Senators stated that they would not even acknowledge his nomination. Here's the kicker, for me at least. McConnell specifically states that many of his Democratic counter parts have said nice things about Gorsuch, and have voted for him in the past. That, of course, is identical to what many Republican Senators had said and done regarding Garland. But McConnell's message is clear, if hypocritical: do as we say, not as we did. 

You can expect a similar level of condescension from McConnell, Paul Ryan, and President Trump's administration as well for any other tactics that the Democrats try to pull. The GOP has the advantage because they've been there, done that. They put the Democrats to a decision for all their chips, the Democrats misplayed their hand badly, and now the GOP is in a power position. The Republicans have the ability to claim, with a seemingly straight face, that the Democrats filibustering Gorsuch would be unprecedented, even as they did even less to acknowledge Garland's nomination. The gridlock in Washington D.C. is shameful, and both parties are to blame for it, but the GOP's ability to say things like McConnell did here with a straight face is really far beyond the skill set of the Democrats. You get the impression he even might believe himself. 

The Democrats hurt themselves, three years ago, by using the so called "nuclear option" to eliminate the filibuster in most situations. Accordingly, it is feasible that the Senate Republicans may do the same if the Democrats actually do muster the strength to filibuster Gorsuch's nomination. The Republicans don't have a super majority, so eliminating the filibuster is one way to get Gorsuch through. A second way, however, if far more in line with their Machiavellian political skill set. If the Democrats try to play their hand via filibuster, I suspect that the GOP will respond with a targeted effort to systematically use the Democrats actions against them in the 2018 Senate races. I think the Republicans are silently hoping that the Trump Administration can stay out of its' own way long enough to allow for a vibrant 2018 calendar to come to fruition for the GOP, particularly in the Senate. But make no mistake: The Supreme Court is high enough stakes by itself that the GOP would use the remaining nuclear option to eliminate the filibuster on nominees to the high court. I just think that is less likely, given where the party is at today. 

At the end of the day, high stakes brinkmanship has become the standard operating procedure for Washington D.C. The Democrats are left pretty helpless, with their only option being to go more extreme than the GOP has in the last number of years. That is scary enough, but particularly if they keep being so bad at guessing where and when to make their moves. Can the Democrats switch the current dynamic and be on the offensive? Are they capable of taking the GOP playbook and making it work for them in a way that doesn't seem disingenuous at best, and which plays into the long term Republican plan at worst? Only time will tell, but one thing is for sure: McConnell is a better poker player than anyone the Democrats have at the present time. 

Wednesday, February 1, 2017

The Wall as a Metaphor? or Can I have Buyers Remorse for $2,000?

I would imagine that most people know someone, even numerous someones, who supported Donald Trump through the last election. While his victory was one of the smallest in modern Presidential history, he did have a lot of people who showed up to vote for him. One of my favorite discussions leading up to the election with these individuals was to ask them their opinions on the handful of positions he had actually articulated. "The Wall" along our southern border being one of his earliest and most consistent talking points, I would often come back to asking them about immigration and, frequently, the wall itself.

What surprised me was this: many, many of the Trump supporters I know resorted to defending him by saying that he didn't mean what he was saying. These individuals would literally say "he won't do that," or "he didn't mean that," or, my favorite, "he didn't say that" (even when there was evidence that either Mr. Trump said it, or a robot built to look exactly like him said it). My favorite defense of Trump's campaign rhetoric, however, was delivered by my brother in law, who told my wife about the aforementioned southern border wall "it's a metaphor ... he doesn't really mean building a wall, he means heightening security." I'd like to say he was the only one, but rationalizations like this were very common among Trump supporters I knew prior to the election.

Of course, within his first ten days in office now President Trump has ordered the construction of the aforementioned wall. It certainly seems less like a metaphor now, as do many other things (special thanks to Rudy Giuliani for deciphering the meaning of the recent immigration related executive order; it's a (probably) legal attempt to get a (mostly) Muslim ban! Can't do it if it isn't constitutional, am I right Rudy?). Trump has, by and large, governed in his first days in office the way he said he was going to govern all along. The fantasy of the "pivot" from campaign Trump to moderate, rational President Trump has, thus far, been as realistic as the fantasy the Never Trumpers had that they would stop him at the convention ... or at the Electoral College ... or any number of other times.

All of this leads me to this article by Nate Silver of fivethirtyeight.com. Mr. Silver notes that "Trump is doing what he said he'd do," and then asks a simple question: "is that what his voters wanted?" I encourage you to read the whole article for the full context, but I think that this is a question of singular importance for both the Republicans and the Democrats. I haven't heard a lot personally from Trump supporters since the election, let alone the inauguration. One can imagine that they are somewhat holding their breath hoping that this works out as well as they fantasized. But this question will drive the midterm elections in 2018, as well as the nominating contest for President on both sides of the aisle in 2020.

President Trump will be 73 going on 74 throughout the 2020 primary process. If his policies have not been popular I can all but guarantee you that he will have to take on numerous challenges throughout the Republican primary season. If his policies, and their resultant outcomes, have been less than popular heading into the 2018 midterms, leading to Democrats holding on or even gaining in the Senate (it's a bad map for the Democrats in 2018, so holding on would be a huge victory), as well as gaining or taking over in the House, it is all but certain that he will face at least some measure of a challenge to be the party's nominee. The last time a serious challenge was mounted against an incumbent was 1980, and let's just say it didn't end too well for the incumbent, President Carter.

To Mr. Silver's point, I do wonder how much buyer's remorse there is going around with people who voted for Trump. There is assuredly a strong portion of those who voted for him who are not only celebrating these executive orders, but are probably bemoaning that they do not go far enough. I have to believe, however, that the totality of those individuals represent little more the the far fringe of the alt-right echo chamber championed by President Trump's "Chief Strategist," Mr. Breitbart himself, Steve Bannon*. The rest of those who voted for Mr. Trump have to be wishing that more of what he said was a metaphor. Even if they are nowhere near ready to admit it yet. But if they are having some buyer's remorse, President Trump and his team would be wise to head their voices, because avoiding becoming a marginalized President, let alone winning re-election, will be difficult if his fairly small coalition begins to splinter.

*As an aside, the uproar over Mr. Bannon joining the National Security Counsel while Mr. Trump functionally demoted the Director of National Intelligence and Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff should get even more attention. Mr. Bannon has done nothing in his personal or professional life that indicates that he is worthy of his current post, let alone this level of influence in the intelligence world. I hope that this continues to be a flash point for the GOP's more foreign policy minded individuals like Senator McCain and Senator Graham. I could also write for thousands of words on Mr. Bannon's involvement alone ... or the less than qualified individuals that President Trump nominated to the various cabinet positions (DeVos, Price and Perry to name three). I could seriously quit my job and do NOTHING but write about all of this and not have enough hours in the day to truly lay out all the intricacies of what's going on. But let me simply say this: it doesn't matter whether you are liberal or conservative, identify as a Democrat or Republican or anywhere in between: Steve Bannon being this involved in our government should terrify you more than almost anything that is going on right now. He makes Karl Rove look like a saint by comparison.