The Moderate strives to present a mainstream, accurate point of view of the world around us, particularly the world of politics.
Monday, February 8, 2021
Governing Is Hard
Wednesday, January 20, 2021
Are You Ready For 2024?
Politics happens fast, and predictions tend to fall to the wayside even faster. In just the last twelve years the Republican Party has been left for dead by media pundits at least twice. First, after the second term of George W. Bush, which resulted in a landslide election that not only brought President Obama to office but also grew strong majorities in the House and Senate. This election led to James Carville writing a book entitled "40 More Years: How the Democrats Will Rule the Next Generation." Of course, Carville's prediction fell just a bit short; before the book could have a paper back printing in 2011 you had the 2010 midterms, which saw the GOP surge to take back the House, and nearly take back the Senate.
And here we are again, with analysis wondering where the GOP will go from here, and think pieces declaring the end of the Republican party. This is, of course, not unprecedented in our history (I'm looking at you Whigs), but it is unlikely. That said, I believe it's clear that Trumpism gives the GOP a bigger stumbling block than the end of the Bush administration did. It's important to recognize key factors why that may be:
1. The GOP finds itself torn in two in a way it hasn't in quite some time. The biggest fault line lies squarely over one of the hallowed centerpieces of conservative politics: small government with balanced budgets. While the GOP hasn't actually believed in these things for years*, they've at least been uniform in professing their belief in these things. Now, you have a populist surge within the Republican party, headed by Trump and articulated by individuals like Josh Hawley (Senator from Missouri) that is in alignment on some issues with Bernie Sanders. While the Presidencies of Reagan and George W Bush saw national debt increases north of 100%, they at least stuck to the talking point of small government and balanced spending. Trump didn't, and now the party is openly split between those who truly seem to believe in these ideals and those who openly do not.
2. Government spending isn't the only place where the GOP finds itself at a crossroads. The merger of the Republican Party with conservative Christians took place over many decades, but crystalized under Karl Rove's leadership during George W Bush's two terms in office. The Presidency of Donald Trump, however, has turned that on its head. Not to say that conservative Christian's are not, by and large, supportive of President Trump. They are; they just have to engage in a lot more mental, ethical and moral gymnastics to get there. This, in turn, has led to some splintering within the "religious right" and GOP coalition. Rove famously pointed out that conservative Christians either vote Republican or they don't vote; George W Bush listened to him where his father didn't, and he ensured that his platform spoke to this group directly. It was an easier sell, however: In Bush you had a born again Christian who genuinely believed what he was saying. In Trump you have the Access Hollywood, multi-divorced, man who has a moral standing that is the anthesis of what Christian conservatives claim to stand for. For many, it was worth it, and the evidence is seen in three names: Gorsuch, Kavanaugh and Coney-Barrett. But, as President Lincoln once sagely put it, a house divided cannot stand. I suspect that the GOP will have a "religious right" problem in the coming years. Some will believe the ends (three conservative, presumably anti-abortion Justices on the Supreme Court) will justify the means, and they will continue to support. Others will say "we got what we wanted, now I'm not going to vote." But regardless the Christian conservatives in this country will face an internal reckoning centered around the hypocrisy of supporting Donald Trump, a man who has very often stood in opposition to Christian principles. Or at least they should.
3. Finally, the Trump Administration led to a third dividing line between the GOP of old and the new order: foreign policy. The coalition of Nixon, Reagan and both Presidents Bush was built on a strong, hawkish US foreign policy. We arm up, we demonstrate power globally, and we fight wars (early and often if possible). President Trump spun this on its' head, seeking to withdraw from international coalitions and agreements, ceding power and influence to China, Russia, and others, and looking to take the US to a more isolationist position**. Again, this is not without precedent (Wilson and FDR were isolationist ahead of the World Wars until they were not), but it is unprecedented in the modern (post WWII) era. What makes it particularly unprecedented is that, under President Trump, the GOP went from being uniformly dominated by hawks to housing portions more dovish than the vast majority of anti-interventionist Democrats.
Taken in total, these three balancing acts (size of government and spending, conservative Christian values, and foreign policy) seem poised to drive the discussion in the build up to 2024, and the Republican primaries. Of course, the success, or lack thereof, of the Biden administration will play a huge role in the GOP nominating process, as will the outcome of the 2022 midterm elections. The Democrats managed to win the White House in 2020, lose seats in the House, and gain seats in the Senate; all told, it was an atypical election year.
Prognosticating this far out is a fraught exercise, but there is reason to believe that the Republicans may take back the House in 2022, while losing another seat or two in the Senate. Imagine, for a moment, that outcome, and couple it with another reasonable outcome: after the 2022 midterm election President Biden announces he will take the James K. Polk route and only serve a single term, declining to run for re-election. Vice President Harris becomes a leading candidate, but certainly not a shoe in (most likely). It is in that unique (albeit imaginary at this point) environment that the Republican Primary in 2024 may take place.
So the Democrats would have the establishment (Harris would likely have a chance to clear this portion of the field unless the Administration is in disarray) face off against the far left (hard to tell this far out, but think AOC or someone of that type of stature). The Republicans, conversely, would have an interparty war between more establishment, traditional members (Ben Sasse, Nikki Haley probably, perhaps John Kasich or Larry Hogan), members trying to straddle the line between Trumpism and the traditional GOP (looking at you Mike Pence, but also Tom Cotton), and those who are fully trying to inherit the championship belt from Trump and declare Trumpism as the new GOP platform (Josh Hawley, maybe Ted Cruz, and yes, quite possibly a Trump - either the 45th President himself looking for a Cleveland like comeback, or Donald Trump Jr.).
It's hard to say who has an advantage in that scenario this far out. At this moment it would seem that Ben Sasse, or those like him, have the inside track given how divided the GOP appears to be. Mike Pence seems to be damaged goods, but a book tour and time on cable news can repair some of that. Hawley and Cruz, to say nothing of the Trumps, seem on the verge of being ostracized at present, but that can swing around quickly to cult hero status. The reality is that the next two years will be crucial in this process. Who will have the largest voice in the minority government. Already, the battle lines are drawn: you're either with Trump (Jim Jordan) or you're the enemy and need to be stripped of all influence (Liz Cheney). Only a Sith deals in absolutes? Try telling that to Trump and his acolytes. The GOP has become a zero sum game all unto itself. I will be paying the closest attention to members who try to have it both ways. It is an unlikely gambit, fraught with pitfalls on both sides, but if a charismatic enough politician can simultaneously claim to be the heir to Reagan and Trump ... well, that person will be a strong candidate in 2024, regardless of what the Biden Administration does, regardless of who is running at the top of the Democratic ticket. The race to 2024 may have informally started, but it officially begins today. Hope you're ready.
*The reigning champion for adding to the national debt remains FDR (and, with a nearly 1,050% increase - yes you read that right - FDR will likely never be topped). But After FDR (the Great Depression and WWII) and Woodrow Wilson (WWI) the next highest increases to the debt by percentage are Reagan (186%) and George W Bush (101%). Obama will stay ahead of Trump, but only due to having served two terms to Trump's one; at the end of one term the debt's growth under Trump exceeds the growth under Obama, who was dealing with the great recession at the time.
**This, in turn, has left the Biden Administration a far more dangerous North Korea and Iran, for example, than the Trump Administration was left by the Obama Administration.
Wednesday, March 15, 2017
So, She's Really Not ... Right?
If you read my first post you know where I stand on this one. I can't fathom Clinton running again, at her age, after being the victim of two huge upsets. Her team collapsed against a relatively unknown Freshman Senator in 2008, and then lost the last election to an opponent who had unprecedentedly low scores in the areas of trustworthiness and likeability. Simply put, voters have made it pretty clear that they don't trust Clinton, don't believe she'd be good for the country, and that, alone, should dissuade her from running again.
Of course, Clinton loyalists will always turn to something: that Obama didn't wait his turn, that the FBI screwed her in this election, that she won the popular vote. But that misses the point. Any truly dynamic candidate never would have lost to an opponent as inexperienced as Obama; they would have beaten Obama and had him as the Vice Presidential nominee. A quality candidate never would have lost to Trump; they would have watched as he self-destructed and would have focused on reinforcing the only areas of the map where Trump could mount his counter measure (the Rust Belt), rather than largely ignoring them.
Nothing would surprise me. Hillary Clinton has spent her life, seemingly, in pursuit of the White House in one way or another, so if she feels she has the drive it wouldn't be shocking for her to put her name in at some point during the run up to 2020. That said, if she does it there will be no possible way to refute the overriding narrative: that she is doing this solely for herself and her own ego, rather than her party or, if she truly believes the Democrats are better for the country, the country itself.
Wednesday, February 15, 2017
Playing Poker With The G.O.P.
Monday, February 6, 2017
Don't Look Back In Anger, I Heard You Say...
If even one of those things wasn't as strongly true it is quite possible she would be in the midst of her first full week as our first female President. Unfortunately for the Clinton political machine, Democrats everywhere, and the Obama legacy, all of those things were not only true, but were dramatically reinforced at every turn by the FBI, Wikileaks, the FBI again, and the rhetoric spewed out by Donald Trump and his team. Say what you want about the man, but for someone who can't stay on topic, he sure is able to stay on topic when it comes to small catch phrases like "crooked Hillary." He can drive those points home.
And so, as I read the article, I was first astonished that the Clintons were reported to be "better understand the forces behind her shocking November defeat." "Can't they just give up?" might have crossed my mind. Then it made some sense, in terms of who Secretary and President Clinton are: they are political animals, driven by politics, and consumed by their passion and drive. So it can't be really surprising that they are delving deep into the county by county returns, and looking for an answer to how they lost an election that they should have won, against an opponent who had (seemingly) done everything wrong. This is who they are, and who they have been. Why should they change now? It is, after all, their life's work.
But that is what drives so much of this country crazy, and what gives credence to the message that helped to carry Trump to the White House. This idea that the political class is obsessed with power, and being in power, to the point that they would do anything for it. That they can't disengage from it. That they pursue it like Gollum pursues the one ring. Politics is a zero sum game, and when a real politician loses I imagine it is hard to just walk away. More pessimistically, absolute power corrupts absolutely. In that sense, I suppose that what Clinton is doing is perfectly normal, and to be expected. I'm sure that she looks back to 2008 and wonders a similar thing: who did I lose to that inexperienced nobody from Illinois. Perhaps that upset loss, which history will validate as an all time upset, should have warned her off from trying again. Perhaps it should have warned the party off, and Obama himself off, from talking Joe Biden out of it. Perhaps she is just star crossed in that sense, and it was never meant to be for her. But I wonder how much she looks back and thinks "if only."
Politics moves on, and somethings don't change. It's the GOP in control of everything now, but already things are feeling eerily similar. The Senators like Lindsey Graham and John McCain are falling in line behind Trump's nominees, after previously indicating that the same things that those nominees have said would be disqualifying for their votes. Trump is nominating a plethora of bankers to nearly every top position he can; he spent the campaign slamming Hillary Clinton for a speech given to Goldman Sachs, while he has all but incorporated Goldman Sachs into the federal government with how much influence he has given their alumni. The Republican Congress is tying their future to Trump because Trump is in power; all the "Never Trump" people are falling quickly, and as quietly as they can in line. And Trump is giving power and influence to the very people he vowed not to: the elite and the bankers, all along side the most extreme voices in the Republican Party.
But the people, particularly in the Rust Belt, seem to dislike the Clinton narrative even more (that's if they are even paying attention to what Trump is actually doing, rather than saying). And that's where stories like this, which paint the "Clinton Machine," as revving up to try to determine their next steps, can only hurt the Democrats in the short term. Hillary Clinton was a flawed candidate who was upset, improbably, twice. As hard as it is for her, it's probably time for her to go away. And, as Oasis said, "don't look back in anger." The remainder of her life will help to write history's ultimate review on her. Stepping away will only serve to improve her standing, most likely, and may give birth to a more positive narrative. It is, at least, the best chance she's got now, because clinging to the illusion of influence will likely only serve to further split her party, and to reinforce Trumps narrative of misdirection.