Monday, January 18, 2021

The Record on the Trump Presidency

 As the sun rises on January 18, 2021, we now find ourselves less than 48 hours from the end of the Trump Presidency. As such, it seemed like a good time to do a brief overview of what his administration accomplished over the last four years. Here, in my opinion, are ten things that were particularly noteworthy (not, necessarily, in any particular order). 

  1. The Trump White House appointed more than 200 judges to the federal bench, nearly as many as President Obama did in two terms. While he appointed fewer than his three predecessors did in two terms, his impact will be most clearly felt in the 54 appellate court Judges appointed. It is not an exaggeration to say that President Trump restructured the federal judiciary in a single term. 
  2. Of course, all of that would have been window dressing had he not accomplished a long time Republican goal of creating a conservative super majority on the Supreme Court. The politicization of the court was covert for years, became more overt with the failed nomination of Robert Bork, and fully flourished with the refusal to even vote on Merrick Garland. But for everything the Trump Administration did or did not accomplish for the GOP faithful, one thing that is indisputable is that McConnell's gambit with Garland's nomination not only paid off, but in spades when coupled with the retirement of Anthony Kennedy and the untimely death of Ruth Bader Ginsberg. Supreme Court Judge's judicial philosophies can be hard to pinpoint (see David Souter as example 1a). Chief Justice John Roberts, a conservative stalwart by most any objective analysis, has already taken on a ton of water for failing to be "conservative enough." Time will tell if Gorsuch has a similar approach to Chief Justice Roberts, or if Kavanaugh or Coney Barrett surprise by being more moderate than Justice's Thomas and Alito. But Trump's reworking of the court to move the center to the right of Chief Justice Roberts is an outcome that will be felt for a generation at least. That is a long lasting accomplishment. 
  3. Donald Trump broke all the rules of diplomacy with North Korea, got some photos out of it, and leaves the USA with a far bigger problem than he inherited. North Korea has continued to invest in and advance not only their nuclear weapons program, but also their delivery systems. Turns out, there are reasons for "conventional wisdom" in cases like North Korea, and reasons why prior administrations, Democrat or Republican, approached the problem in fairly similar ways. You can't just go rogue with foreign policy and expect it to work out well.
  4. To that end, the Trump administration's decision to withdraw from the Iranian Nuclear Deal was consequential, and also a complete disaster. Many of my Trump apologist friends and family like to point to the Iran agreement as a failure of the Obama Administration, without knowing anything about the complexities of nuclear non-proliferation or the difficulty of actually delivering a multi-national agreement like the Iranian Nuclear Deal. As far back as 2014 there were strong signs that the Iran deal was working; instead, now we are left with a rapidly advancing Iranian nuclear program, the USA with a damaged reputation for future negotiations, and increasing likelihood of conflict with Iran leading to some sort of war. Simply put, the Iranian Nuclear Deal was the best of a series of bad options the world was left with to contain the Iranian nuclear program; Trump's hatred of all things Obama, coupled with he and his team's lack of skill in international relations, have led the world far closer to the Iranians crossing the breakout threshold and creating their own nuclear arsenal. 
  5. President Trump took office with a Republican majority in both the House and the Senate. He ran promising to repeal and replace the Affordable Care Act. He never could quite get the votes to repeal (insert John McCain thumbs down) and he never published anything remotely resembling a plan to replace. This talking point was a fraud on Republican votes; he never intended to replace the ACA with anything, just as President George W Bush campaigned openly in 2004 about an Amendment to the Constitution barring same sex marriage, but never intended to act on it. 
  6. President Trump undoubtedly moved the party to the right, making it so that staunch conservatives like John Boehner, Paul Ryan, and Jeff Flake had to leave political office because they quickly became "Republicans In Name Only." You see the same thing happening right now with Liz Cheney. They eat their own, and the last four years have made that vibrantly clear. 
  7. Under Trump there were tax cuts. He may not have been able to deliver repeal and replace, but his unified GOP government at least cut taxes. Of course, more than 60% of the savings went to the top 20% of income earners in the country, while corporations continued to find ways to dodge paying taxes. And the tax cuts didn't really impact economic growth. TL;DR? The rich got richer, the poor got poorer, the deficit got larger, and most of us didn't really see much change at all. 
  8. President Trump may not have been able to do anything else of legislative consequence, but he did take unilateral action whenever and where ever he could. One area that will likely have long lasting impact was his decision to pull the US out of the Paris Climate Accord. Climate change is real, and it is an existential threat to not only the USA but every living being on this planet. I cannot believe that Republicans haven't found a way to make this into a winning issue; the economy of the future will be dominated by those who master clean energy. That said, this action was short sighted and, again, seemed mostly driven by not liking it simply because the prior administration did it. Similar to the attempted action with the ACA, and the action with the Iranian Nuclear Accords. As well as pulling out of NAFTA only to renegotiate an extremely similar deal. Seems like you might be able to say that President Trump didn't like his predecessor. 
  9. Of course, on his watch the GOP also lost the 2018 midterm elections in historic fashion, and he became the first President since Benjamin Harrison (1888) to lose the popular vote twice. This may say something more broadly about the GOP coalition, however, as they have now lost the popular vote for the Presidency in 1992, 1996, 2000, 2008, 2012, 2016 and 2020. 
  10. Finally, President Trump became only the third President to be Impeached, in 2019, and then became the only President to be Impeached twice, in the waning days of his Administration. He is now the record holder; it is not uncommon for members of the House to submit Articles of Impeachment, but it is rare for there to actually be a hearing, for their to be a vote on it. Numerous times during the George W Bush administration there were rumblings of potential Impeachment, but it never came to pass. Trump managed to commit Impeachable offenses throughout his time in office, to the degree that he was actually Impeached twice. 
Certainly a history making four years. 

Thursday, January 14, 2021

Will We Not Survive Ourselves?

 "We crossed the oceans wide, built cities to the sky oh lord. Looked up and we were flying. But will we not survive ourselves?" - Dave Matthew Band, Gaucho

This lyric stuck in my head over the last week as I read numerous think pieces regarding President Trump and his need to either A) resign the Presidency, B) have his powers removed by his Cabinet and Vice President via the 25th Amendment, or C) be Impeached and tried. I am not going to write thousands of words on this (although I could), but I did want to jump on to lay out a few points about why it is important to have a check on Presidential power, and the significant risk we find ourselves in as a country and civilization.

I suspect most people have never heard of James Schlesinger. He was the Secretary of Defense under President Nixon, a man who took an action that can simultaneously be celebrated and condemned - and neither side would be wrong. In 1974 President Nixon was nearing resignation, and was, by all accounts, not well mentally. He was drinking to excess, and scheming ways to stay in power. He was even reported to have joked about dropping a nuclear bomb on Capitol Hill as Congress moved to impeach him. This nuclear fantasy wasn't isolated; he also is reported to have made a point of saying "I can go into my office and pick up the telephone, and in 25 minutes 70 million people will be dead."  

Secretary Schlesinger helped to make that not possible, as he separated the nuclear codes from President Nixon, further insisting that any order to launch be cleared by him or National Security Advisor Henry Kissinger first. Many of the things that led to Secretary Schlesinger's unprecedented action in 1974 are present today: a damaged, mentally unwell President scheming for ways to stay in power, desperate and fearing for his own legal liability. Secretary Schlesinger acted in a way that could accurately be described as simultaneously patriotic and mutinous. He acted to save the world, while also undermining the chain of command to his Commander in Chief. This article, entitled "The Most Patriotic Act of Treason in American History" sums it up well, just in the title. (If you're interested in learning more about this period of time, including Nixon, the nuclear codes, and the relevance to this discussion today, check out this article.)

There is no doubt in my mind that President Trump hoped that the violent insurrection on January 6th, 2021 would lead to him staying in power. Foreign policy experts like Fiona Hill and Timothy Snyder have given detailed explanations about why this was, in fact, a coup attempt, and how Trump's actions closely align with failed dictators, but didn't deviate too far from those of successful dictators. I won't rehash their well researched, well reasoned articles here. I will strongly encourage you to read them for context to this entire discussion. Those who would say that President Trump didn't attempt a coup, didn't attempt to move us towards an authoritarian dictatorship, and didn't directly seek to undermine democracy in our country are simply lying: either to themselves, or to you. He did, and in that context, we need to revisit Secretary Schlesinger's actions in the context of 2021 and beyond. 

Joe Cirincione is one of the leading minds in the area of nuclear non-proliferation. His book, Deadly Arsenals: Nuclear, Biological and Chemical Threats was a key resources in my education in international relations. The book opens with this statement:

"The proliferation of nuclear, biological, and chemical weapons is widely recognized as the most serious threat to the national security of the United States and other nations." 

In the 15 plus years since the second edition of this book was published, the only thing that I would add is that climate change has probably wedged itself in there on equal footing. That said, the nuclear age undoubtedly brought challenges, and we face those challenges still today. Cirincione is one of the most established and respected minds in foreign policy when it comes to nuclear non-proliferation, nuclear security/diplomacy, and weapons systems (including their realistic use and limitations). He writes for Responsible Statecraft these days, and it is his most recent article, from January 13, 2021, that I want to end by reflecting on. 

Cirincione opens by reflecting on Speaker Pelosi's concerns about President Trump, in his closing days, being unfit to have nuclear launch capability at his disposal. Of course, if you followed the news you know that Speaker Pelosi says she was assured by the Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, General Milley, that there were checks in place to stop the President from acting on any impulse to start a war (most likely, Cirincinoe correctly points out, with Iran; my concerns here could fill another post). Of course, if General Milley or any other military member ignored the President's direct order, they would be violating their chain of command, which would be mutiny.

Cirincione explains, in readily accessible detail, the reason that the system is set up as it is (for the President to be able to authorize a nuclear strike by himself without secondary approval). Cirincione also explains why that needs to change, and then suggests how to do it: 

"It must be at the top of Joe Biden's agenda to change the obsolete policies that make this nightmare scenario possible. One, end the first-strike policy so that any order to fire nuclear weapons first is illegal. Two, take weapons off high alert so that they cannot be launched in minutes, allowing more time for deliberation and reconsideration of launch orders. Three, end the sole authority of any president to start a nuclear way by requiring at the top what we require all the rest of the way down the launch chain: two must agree to launch." 

This makes good sense. If nuclear weapons are to be a meaningful deterrent (and I am of the mindset that they are), then we should make it clear they are a deterrent, not a first strike option. This would not limit our ability, as a nation, to defend ourselves, nor would it limit our ability to respond to nuclear aggression in kind. It would simply reduce the likelihood of a desperate or unwell politician at the top of the launch command making a mistake for which all of civilization will pay. 

Of particular note, Cirincione ends by explaining that many of these actions Biden can take immediately upon taking office, through executive orders. Other actions, such as treaties for arms reduction both alone and in concert with other nations, require Congressional approval. But it is long past time for us to stop celebrating what Secretary Schlesinger did, to stop putting our hope in what General Milley says he would do, and instead recognize that putting our military or civilian servants in the position of having to engage in a mutinous action to save the world is unacceptable. 

This week has shown that these actions are all the more important, given the extreme polarization in our country that makes it so A) the President won't resign because there isn't a critical mass of Republicans calling for it, B) the Cabinet and Vice President won't act because they see it as giving in to the other side, and C) the Senate might convict, or it might not, but they won't act quickly in any event. Our political polarization has led us to a moment where most Americans, and even most in Congress, are in agreement that the President is too unsafe to have a Twitter account, but we cannot act uniformly to remove him from the nuclear codes without banking on someone engaging in mutiny to do it. That's dumb policy, and it has to change. 

Monday, January 11, 2021

A Republic, If You Can Keep It

 It's been not quite four years since I last posted here. I started this blog as President Trump took office, with an opening post going live on January 22, 2017, two days after inauguration day. At that time, I laid out the reason I was starting this blog:

"I hope that this can become a part of a broader discussion, at least within my own small world, to enhance the nature of discourse and, in my own way, to help all get back on track. The future of our society very well may depend on it." 

The future of society line, of course, was related to the need for broader discussion and improved discourse in our society about politics. And so I started off trying to post twice weekly, focused on what was going on in the county, in politics, sharing my experience, education, and perspective. 

Nineteen posts. That's all the further I made it in this endeavor. Nineteen posts between January 22, 2017 and April 12, 2017. And then I stopped, and haven't come back until today. I can come up with lots of excuses, all of which have some degree of truth. I got busy. Life got complicated. I sincerely doubt the value that my perspective brings to the broader discourse, and there is a part of me that suspects that writing in any way, but particularly this way is little more than a one person ego trip. Instead I journaled, discussed with close friends, and thought a lot. But all of those things, and so many other things, are window dressing to the real reason that this blog got shuttered just shy of three months after I launched it. 

This is the real reason: I could not find a way to put the Presidency of Donald J. Trump into any context. I could not find a way to be "middle of the road" when taking an objective view of his actions, or many of the actions of those around him. Simply put, I found myself rapidly incapable of trying to bring any sense of logic to an illogical situation, and found myself increasingly frustrated by those who cheered the actions of the President. 

I noted, in that first introduction, that I wanted to own that I was not a Trump supporter, stating:

"I cannot imagine what it would have taken to get me to vote for the man ... I identify as a moderate Republican, lining up more as an independent these days than anything else." 

That said, I intended to try to put Trump's Presidency into a more balanced context, recognizing that the nature of our country at this time lent itself to extreme polarization. In that effort I quickly recognized I would fail, and therefore I retreated. I recognized I was unable to pretend that the President of the United States was anything other than a racist, sexist, wannabe strong man demagogue. And, with that reality I also recognized that I was unable to engage in discourse regarding this man in a productive way with broader society. It quickly became hard enough, and often impossible, to do so with my family and close friends who drank the Trump Kool aide. 

On January 6, 2021 the full Congress met to certify the Electoral College results. You don't need me to repeat all the talking points about this day that were offered up ahead of it: ceremonial, routine, usually gets no publicity at all, etc. The reality is that the Congressional certification of the Electoral College results is a non-story. But the reason you heard all these things ahead of this day was that everyone knew that some way, some how, this day would be different. There was a protest planned, and President Trump would be speaking at it. Nobody knew exactly what would happen, but anyone who had paid a lick of attention to the politics of President Trump since he became candidate Trump in 2015 knew that whatever happened would be unprecedented and it wouldn't be good. 

 President Trump spoke to the protestors after a warm up from his son (Donald Trump Jr.) and his personal lawyer (Rudy Giuliani), both of whom stoked the fires in their own way. He then took the podium and spewed the same dictator-lite fundamental lie he had been spewing since the GOP Primaries in 2016: any election in which he did not win was stolen, a hoax, and either needed to be redone or overturned. That is reality; his actions on January 6, 2021 were not fundamentally different than his response to losing the Iowa Caucus to Ted Cruz in 2016. It was always the same playbook, and it was taken from men like Putin, Un and Khamenei, who took it from men like Stalin, Hitler and Mussolini, who modified it from the well established plans to maintain power from Kings and Emperors of civilizations past. 

Please understand that this is historical fact when I tell you this: what Donald J. Trump attempted to do (and is, undoubtedly, still trying to find a way to do as I write this) is not new, unprecedented, or unheard of. It happens the world over every year, and has since the first forms of government. To be led by a strong-man dictator (whatever the title) is the most common form of government in human history. To be led by a democratically elected head of state who transfers power when they are voted out is extremely rare. 

There are many reasons for this, but perhaps the most compelling I've ever read is over two thousand years old. Plato, in his political philosophy classic Republic stated:

"There can be no doubt that the love of wealth and the spirit of moderation cannot exist together in citizens of the same State to any considerable extent; one or the other will be disregarded." 

Put another way, by Lord John Dalberg-Acton: 

"Power tends to corrupt, and absolute power corrupts absolutely. Great men are almost always bad men..." 

These realities are part of what led to our Constitution's unique qualities of separation of powers, including the Executive Branch, the Congress and the Courts. Of course, some of our government is related to the second line of the Lord Acton quote. We have a government by the people, for the people, but we have an Electoral College because the Founding Fathers didn't trust the "common" man to vote for the President (or Senators for that matter). And, of course, the Founding Fathers had to create a system that worked within the context of "State's rights" which, at the time, was the context for the discussion on our nation's original sin, slavery. Benjamin Franklin acknowledged that the pursuit of a more perfect union was inherently flawed based on the men who led the pursuit, stating in his final speech at the Constitutional Convention that:

"...when you assemble a number of men to have the advantage of their joint wisdom, you inevitably assemble with those men, all their prejudices, their passions, their errors of opinion, their local interest, and their selfish views."

All eligible voters have a voice in our democracy, but it is watered down and limited in very real ways. If I lived in Wyoming, I would have over three times the voting power in my single vote than the average American; if I lived in California, by contrast, my vote would be worth only .85 the average American. And, of course, ending this tangent, the Electoral College doesn't just do crazy things with vote value like that, it also ensures that out of our 50 states only a handful will "really matter" each year. In 2020, like 2016, Pennsylvania, Michigan and Wisconsin were the big three with a few other states on the periphery. 

These last paragraphs were sidebars to the broader context of this post, and what I'm hoping to convey. If you aren't familiar with the title of this post, it comes from a quote attributed to Benjamin Franklin following the Constitutional Convention. Asked what kind of government the people had been given, Franklin is said to have replied:

"A republic, if you can keep it." 

Franklin is also reported to have said:

"Our new Constitution is now established, everything seems to promise it will be durable; but, in this world, nothing is certain except death and taxes." 

Our Constitution is facing one of the greatest threats it has since it was signed into the guiding law of the land. We, collectively, are the heirs and heiresses to a form of government that survived September 11, 2001, The Cold War and Vietnam, The Great Depression, two World Wars, the corruption of the Gilded Age, a Civil War and countless other challenges going all the way back to what was one of the first, and perhaps the greatest challenge: the peaceful transfer of power in the first contested election. We passed that challenge in 1796, as Washington stepped down and John Adams took his place. Four years later, with more drama, the Presidency passed peacefully from Adams to Thomas Jefferson. These two elections, 1976 and 1800, set the standard for our form of government. 

The 2016 election was the first since that had such a degree of uncertainty regarding the fundamental peaceful transfer of power. We were delayed four years in seeing what would happen if Donald J. Trump lost, because he won due to the Electoral College in 2016. What he has shown since election day 2020 cannot be a surprise to anyone who was paying attention since 2015. And still, surprising or not, it cuts to the very heart of what Franklin was warning against in the immediate aftermath of the Constitutional Convention, to the very core of what Plato and Lord Acton were saying. 

Human beings are terrible historians at large; we tend to live very much in the present, with limited awareness of the past and an inability to imagine a future different than today. Given that, it is unsurprising that so many of my fellow Americans would gleefully assume that our form of government will be tomorrow as it was yesterday. In the days, weeks and months to come there will be revisionist history about the events of this past week, past months, past years. We will hear about all the good that came from the Trump Presidency (read: lower taxes for the wealthy, booming 401Ks, and I'm sure some other things that I can't even wrap my head around enough to type them). We will hear that all he wanted was to ensure the election was fair, that it wasn't his supporters who stormed the Capitol and attempted to violently overthrow the very Constitutional Government that President Trump took an oath to protect. We will hear hairbrained theories that it was actually far left radicals who did the storming, in spite of a clear lack of evidence for it. We will hear more about how there were voting irregularities in the 2020 election, in spite of the absolute lack of evidence of any wide spread, abnormal irregularities. We are already hearing that anyone who would suggest that President Trump should be removed from office, Impeached and found guilty of treason, and barred from future office isn't trying to unify the country, and is therefore in the wrong. The spin, my friends, goes on. 

And yes, I ramble, but I ramble towards a broader point: our American Government and way of life is not something that is just "given." It must be fought for, and not in the military sense. It must be fought for and protected day in and day out by a citizenry that educates itself, engages in active discourse, and seeks to find the centrist truth rather than being wooed by the seductive extremes. It must be fought for by placing the wellbeing of others ahead of the absolute pursuit of personal wealth and power. It must be fought for by recognizing demagoguery on any side of the aisle and seeking to strike it down through emphatic use of the vote. It must be fought for by ensuring that everyone with the right to vote is clear about how to exercise that right, should they so choose, and that they are supported in doing so if they desire. It must be fought for by speaking truth to power as clearly and plainly as possible.

And so, at the end of this post, here is my truth to power:

  • Donald J. Trump is a racist, sexist, power hungry fear monger. He is a con-man, a snake oil salesman, and a demagogue who fancies himself a strong man. Thank God (and I mean that literally) that he was not more gifted as a politician, or our way of Government would likely have ended. As it was, he managed to put it on life support. 
  • President Trump, however, is not the cause of our problems; he is simply the most vibrant symptom. He is the worst of all of us, the manifestation of the poison we have let seep into our nation through cable news, social media, and other platforms that divide us rather than unite us. 
  • Those who marched on and broke into the Capitol are domestic terrorists. There is no other way to put it, and all should be tried for whatever is viable to the fullest extent of the law. 
  • President Trump, himself, was the leader of this movement. He should be barred from seeking future office by an overwhelming bipartisan majority of both houses of Congress. Anyone who doesn't support that effort clearly is valuing their own power more than the viability of the form of government they swore an oath to protect and uphold. 
  • Further, President Trump should not receive any pardon for his actions; he must be tried and held accountable to the fullest extent of the law. Absent this, we simply leave the door open with a huge sign saying "please try again" to a more gifted politician who won't be a wanna be strong man because he'll achieve Trump's goal. 
  • The Senators and House Members who pushed the façade should be censured, and be held to answer for their actions, particularly those who insisted on carrying on after the assault on the Capitol. In an ideal world, they would be dealt with the same as the Senators who refused to acknowledge the Presidency of Abraham Lincoln. 
  • Anyone still supporting this man is either blind to the facts and willfully ignorant or, worse, is the type of person who encourages white supremacy, marginalizing others because of their race, ethnicity or gender, and is okay watching the world burn so long as they believe they'll come out ahead. 
It is on this last point that I will expound for a moment, and then end. I stopped writing because I realized I could not find the words to engage with those I most needed to: Trump supporters who were not horrified by what we had witnessed in his first 100 days in office. Logic was seemingly incapable of entering discussion with them, and I found my heart hardening towards them. At the end of 2019, in deep personal reflection, I realized that I needed to find a way to do better. 2020, instead, threw a ton of other things my way that took my time and attention, and my personal pursuit of becoming a better human being fell largely by the wayside, with the focus on the very real problems of today. 

Today I listened to a sermon that really drove the point home: we cannot hope to defeat bad with bad. We must rise above and fight evil with good. To be clear, the Trump supporters who stormed the capital must be tried, and the laws of this land must be upheld vibrantly to guard against future attempts of overthrowing the government. There will be more in the future, and we must guard strongly against it. But most of the 75,000,000 people who voted for President Trump were not there on January 6, 2021. Many of them, perhaps most, are not driven by harming or marginalizing others. They are driven by fear, and fueled by misinformation which is far easier to come by than well vetted fact. The world around them is changing, and they fear the loss that comes with change. Loss of power, loss of certainty, loss of understanding the world around them. Fear is powerful; President Trump knows this, which is why he led with fear early, often, and throughout his time as a candidate and in office. I believe that most of his supporters are afraid, and they let their fear blind them to reality.

It is these individuals that we all must find a way to engage with. We must find a way to come back towards the rational, reasoned, educated middle. I am still, as I was when I started this blog in January of 2017, a moderate, centrist, political being. If I cannot engage effectively with my brothers and sisters to the right of me, so be it. But I need to seek to understand their point of view, and try, as best I am able, to engage with them, and with those to the left of me in the same way. I like to believe that there is a large majority in this country, 80% or so of us, who can come to rational agreements on things like healthcare, energy policy, gun regulations and rights, voting rights ... the list goes on and on. 

Certainly, my discussions with friends and family on these issues tend to support this idea, but if it is true then clearly our representation in Washington is driven by and drives towards the 20% fringes. The only way to get our government to truly be by the people and for the people will be for us to start talking again, and to stop allowing fear to divide us. I hope and pray that out of the ashes of the last four years, from this flirtation with authoritarian government, we might close that door and instead march together towards a better, more democratic future. Our American way of life is only ours if we can keep it. History says we cannot succeed in this effort; only time will tell if we can overcome the pull of greed and fear and leave Trump the aberration, or if his Presidency was merely the prelude.  

Wednesday, April 12, 2017

The Incompetent Presidency

I know that President Trump, his administration, and his die hard supporters will just scream "fake news," but can't help but be somewhat stunned when a well established conservative publication like The National Review publishes something like this article. I suppose, however, that it is unavoidable due to the complete ineptitude displayed by the Trump Administration nearly three months into assuming the office.

The first 100 days is typically a time where a new administration passes a good many new initiatives, strengthened by the political capital and "mandate" stemming from the election. In the case where the President has entered office without a resounding mandate, such as the 2000 election and George W. Bush, the administration has typically worked aggressively with the other party to achieve bipartisan legislative achievements. These are the two options, historically and for good reason: if you have the capital you should use it before circumstances dictate that you lose it. If you don't have the capital, working with the other side can garner respect and support in the event that you gain it in the future.

The Trump Administration, inexplicably, has seemingly settled on a third option: go to war with everyone. Accordingly, it seems likely at this point that they will end their first 100 days without a single headline achievement on which to rest their hats. The buildup to the midterm election will be fast and furious this time around, similar to what was observed in 1994 or 2010. An Administration without a mandate (no President in modern times has had less of a mandate than President Trump did upon taking the oath of office) has decided to try to operate by strong arming people. He has served to stir up the opposition to the point where they are apparently poised to oppose nearly everything. He has also served to further fracture his own party, splitting off extreme and moderate portions of his party already.

In sum, it is inarguable at this point that this administration is ill equipped for the responsibility of governing. With issues spiraling out of control in the realm of foreign policy (Syria and North Korea most disconcertingly), and with their own administration in the line of fire for a series of apparent lies told by campaign and administration personnel regarding their own involvement with Russia, as well as the President's own inability to stay out of his own way on social media, it seems simultaneously essential that the administration somehow rush through their own steep learning curve and catastrophically impossible that they can learn at all. Three months in things look bad. They are poised to look a lot worse in three months if there isn't a miraculous turnaround hidden just out of sight.

Wednesday, April 5, 2017

What The Health Care Failure Means

An insane amount has happened in the last twenty plus days. I'm back, albeit in a shortened version due to time constraints. That said, I wanted to dip my toe in and give some brief analysis on the failure of the GOP to pass their own "health care" bill, leading to Speaker Ryan saying that the Affordable Care Act would be the law of the land for the foreseeable future.

The fundamental flaw in the GOP attempt was that the bill, while positioned as a health care reform bill, was actually anything but. The bill fundamentally did a few things. It cut taxes, predominately on the wealthiest of Americans. It shifted the cost of healthcare from the federal government to state governments. It rolled back many regulations in the ACA which were put in place to help control costs. And it ultimately projected to reduce the deficit over ten years, while controlling the rising cost of healthcare within a decade, ever so slightly, at the cost of roughly 24 million Americans losing insurance.

None of that actually tackles the problem of health care in this country. The USA is by and large one of the least heavily taxed nations in the industrialized/western world. In fact, the other nations, taken together and averaged, have a tax rate roughly ten percent higher than the US rate. Only two counties (Mexico and Chile) have lower rates than the USA. In spite of significantly reducing the tax burden on citizens over the last fifty years, the government has not reigned in spending. Accordingly, deficits continue to grow, damaging the country's financial stability long term. That, in turn, leads to a great hesitation to spend in areas like health care, where it is an unassailable fact that the uninsured lead to the greatest degree of unpaid cost in the system, which, in turn, is the primary contributing factor to the increasing cost of health care that everyone else feels.

Since the end of the Reagan years the top tax rate in the USA has sat between 39.6% (Clinton years) and 28% (end of Reagan's second term). More specifically, through the last three Presidency's the rate  been no higher than 39.6% and no lower than 35%. Prior to Reagan, however, the tax rate sat between 70% and 77% for nearly 20 years, and was significantly higher than that throughout world war two and the ensuing two decades. Many of the "Reagan Democrats" in the Rust Belt talk of wanting to go back to an economy that existed in the 1950s and 1960s. I've talked here before about some of the reasons why that is impractical and impossible, but looking at the tax rates that were involved during that period of time is yet another factor.

What does all this have to do with health care? Well, first, the GOP "attempt" to "repeal and replace" the Affordable Care Act was actually an attempt to repeal parts of the ACA and to cut taxes. There wasn't any functional aspect to it that dealt with the issues facing our health care system. In no particular order, those issues are:

1. Costs which are spiraling out of control, due to;
2. Malpractice lawsuits being around every corner, leading to
3. Increasing costs for malpractice insurance for medical providers.
Additionally:
4. Uninsured people going to the ER to get medical care for any medical concern, because hospitals cannot refuse them care, then
5. Not paying their bills, leading to
6. Hospitals losing money, leading to
7. Medical providers increasing the price they charge for services, leading to
8. Government health care providers refusing to pay the high price, leading to
9. an ever smaller network of providers who will accept Medicare and Medicaid, leading to
10. Fewer choices and
11. High costs in premiums and deductibles for everyone.

I could go on and on with this list, but that's the general gist. In the midst of this the GOP claims to want to reform healthcare, but if their first attempt is any indication they haven't even really given the problems with the system much thought. In fact, given that their first attempt would have uninsured another 24 million people, one could argue that they were willing to exacerbate many of these problems to give the best off in this country even more money in their pockets. But look back at those tax rates I mentioned earlier: do people really, really need that additional money in their pockets? And, if they have it, will it even pay for their increased medical costs?

Ultimately, the two extremes of this debate are to go with a government run single payer system (universal health care as a right), or to remove all legislation mandating care, making it so that health care is truly governed by the forces of capitalism (if you can't pay you don't get the service, period). In between is where we've been for sometime, and where we figure to be for sometime more. Ultimately, what his failure to pass a repeal and replace means is that the GOP spent seven years running against the ACA without actually coming up with a plan to replace it. It also means that they might be far better suited to being the minority party than the majority. Governing is hard after all.

Wednesday, March 15, 2017

So, She's Really Not ... Right?

In this post I talked a bit about Hillary Clinton and her team thinking about what the future might bring. Well, in the interim, two competing articles were published. The first, from Politico, comes right out to declare that Clinton will run for President, yet again, in 2020. The second, from The Washington Post, talks about the importance of Democrats stopping Clinton from running again, and declares that she absolutely should not run again.

If you read my first post you know where I stand on this one. I can't fathom Clinton running again, at her age, after being the victim of two huge upsets. Her team collapsed against a relatively unknown Freshman Senator in 2008, and then lost the last election to an opponent who had unprecedentedly low scores in the areas of trustworthiness and likeability. Simply put, voters have made it pretty clear that they don't trust Clinton, don't believe she'd be good for the country, and that, alone, should dissuade her from running again.

Of course, Clinton loyalists will always turn to something: that Obama didn't wait his turn, that the FBI screwed her in this election, that she won the popular vote. But that misses the point. Any truly dynamic candidate never would have lost to an opponent as inexperienced as Obama; they would have beaten Obama and had him as the Vice Presidential nominee. A quality candidate never would have lost to Trump; they would have watched as he self-destructed and would have focused on reinforcing the only areas of the map where Trump could mount his counter measure (the Rust Belt), rather than largely ignoring them.

Nothing would surprise me. Hillary Clinton has spent her life, seemingly, in pursuit of the White House in one way or another, so if she feels she has the drive it wouldn't be shocking for her to put her name in at some point during the run up to 2020. That said, if she does it there will be no possible way to refute the overriding narrative: that she is doing this solely for herself and her own ego, rather than her party or, if she truly believes the Democrats are better for the country, the country itself.

Wednesday, March 8, 2017

A New Cold War? One New Yorker Article Hypothesizes As Much

This article, posted in the New Yorker, takes a deep dive into the world of foreign relations as it relates to the United States and Russia. The article is certainly an interesting take to consider. I would implore people out there to take in information like this, and to consider what it might mean moving forward. The far right media will cry foul throughout this process, accusing the process of "media bias" or being "fake news," but in reality there is much more meat on the bones than they'd want to admit.

The interesting thing about this current Administration's (mostly) overt pro-Russian bent is how counter it runs to the general GOP's recent approach to Russia. Using history as a lens through which to view current relations between the countries is not only practical, but a proven method for trying to decode international relations and what's likely to happen going forward. The same rationale applies to looking at the fall of democracies and empires past when looking at our own governmental institutions. Doing so isn't the same as saying those things will happen, but simply indicates that the possibility is always there, and being aware of what things were antecedents in the past might help to avoid a similar fate in the present.

In sum, I'd encourage you to read the article linked above, regardless of your viewpoint. It doesn't hurt to broaden our horizons and consider possible outcomes, no matter how plausible we individually believe they might be. After all, I doubt too many Romans foresaw the fall of Rome in the way it ultimately happened, nor did citizens of the British Empire at the turn of the 20th century. Time is relentless, and, as the saying goes, those ignorant of history are bound to repeat it.